Guide

Dave Portnoy's pizza reviews: the One Bite story

How a Barstool Sports bit about eating one slice of cheese pizza turned into the most-watched pizza rating system in America — and what 2,048 reviews tell us about where to eat.

Who is Dave Portnoy?

Dave Portnoy founded Barstool Sports in 2003 as a free sports and gambling newspaper handed out around Boston. Over two decades it grew into one of the biggest digital media brands in sports and comedy, with blogs, podcasts and video shows. Portnoy, who goes by "El Presidente," has stayed its most recognizable face — and since the early 2010s, a big part of that face has been him standing outside a pizzeria holding a slice.

Barstool's ownership has changed hands a few times. The Chernin Group invested in 2016, Penn Entertainment bought in starting in 2020 and took full ownership in 2023, then sold the company back to Portnoy later that year. Through all of it, the pizza reviews kept rolling.

How the One Bite pizza reviews started

The oldest pizza review video in Barstool's public archive is from March 2013: a bar pizza review in Massachusetts, filmed with very little production. The early reviews were short, unpolished clips of Portnoy walking up to local spots and giving his verdict. The format took off after Barstool opened its New York office in 2016 and Portnoy started reviewing several pizzerias a day around Manhattan and Brooklyn.

The rules never really changed. He orders a plain cheese pie or slice, usually takes it outside, shows off the undercarriage, folds or doesn't fold, and takes one bite. Then comes the number: a score out of 10, to one decimal place. "One bite, everybody knows the rules."

Here is how many reviews in our directory were posted each year, based on Barstool's video archive:

One Bite reviews by year
YearReviews
20134
20141
20152
201618
2017104
2018138
2019193
2020128
2021167
2022208
2023235
2024193
2025159
202691

What Dave Portnoy looks for in a slice

Portnoy has never published a formal rubric, but watch enough reviews and the patterns are obvious. He's judging a plain cheese slice, so there's nowhere to hide:

Read more in how One Bite scores work, and see what each pizza style is supposed to taste like.

Dave Portnoy's highest-rated pizzerias

These are the top One Bite scores in our data. The overall average is 6.85, so anything in the high 8s and up is rare air.

  1. Monte's Restaurant — Lynn, MA: 10.0
  2. DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza — Raritan, NJ: 9.4
  3. Di Fara Pizza — Brooklyn, NY: 9.4
  4. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana — Chestnut Hill, MA: 9.4
  5. Luigi's Pizza — Brooklyn, NY: 9.3
  6. Lazzara's Pizza — New York, NY: 9.3
  7. Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria — New York, NY: 9.3
  8. John's of Bleecker Street — New York, NY: 9.3
  9. Lucali — Brooklyn, NY: 9.3
  10. Oath Pizza — Nantucket, MA: 9.3
  11. Ceres — New York, NY: 9.2
  12. De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies — Robbinsville, NJ: 9.2

See the full One Bite rankings →

Where Dave Portnoy reviews the most pizza

Portnoy reviews where he lives and travels, so New York dominates, followed by the Northeast and the places Barstool goes for games and events.

Beyond pizzerias: frozen pizza, festivals and the app

Portnoy also reviews supermarket frozen pizza — 66 of them so far, ranked on our frozen pizza rankings page. Barstool has also run a One Bite Pizza Festival in Brooklyn, bracket-style pizza tournaments, and the official One Bite app, where fans can see every review on a map and post their own scores. More on that on our One Bite app page.

The "One Bite bump"

Local news outlets regularly report pizzerias seeing lines out the door after a strong score. A good number can turn a neighborhood slice shop into a destination overnight; a bad one becomes a meme. That's a big reason fans keep track — and why we built this directory.

Dave Portnoy pizza review FAQ

Who is Dave Portnoy?

Dave Portnoy is the founder of Barstool Sports, the sports and pop-culture media company he started in the Boston area in 2003. He is also known as "El Presidente" and is the face of the One Bite pizza reviews.

What is the best pizza Dave Portnoy has ever had?

By score, Monte's Restaurant in Lynn, MA (10.0) sits at the top of our data, followed by DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza (9.4), Di Fara Pizza (9.4), Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (9.4).

Why does Dave Portnoy only take one bite?

One bite is the format: the first bite of a plain slice tells you most of what you need to know about the crust, sauce and cheese. It is also how he can review several pizzerias in a day. The catchphrase is "One bite, everybody knows the rules."

Where can I see all of Dave Portnoy's pizza reviews?

Barstool Sports posts the videos on its site and social channels, and the official One Bite app collects every review with a map and scores. This fan site organizes them by state, city and pizza style.

Has Dave Portnoy ever given a pizza a 0?

Yes. 6 pizzerias in our data scored a 0.0, the bottom of the scale.

One Bite Pizza Reviews is an unofficial fan site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy or the One Bite app. Scores are reported from public sources; names and trademarks belong to their owners.