Data
Barstool pizza reviews, by the numbers
What 1,143 scored Barstool Sports One Bite reviews say about the best pizza cities, states and styles in America. Average score: 6.85.
How Barstool pizza scores are distributed
Dave Portnoy's scale runs 0 to 10, but in practice almost everything lands between 6 and 8. That's why a 7.5 is a good result and an 8.5 is news.
| Score | Pizzerias | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 9.0 and up | 23 | 2.0% |
| 8.0 – 8.9 | 165 | 14.4% |
| 7.0 – 7.9 | 495 | 43.3% |
| 6.0 – 6.9 | 281 | 24.6% |
| 5.0 – 5.9 | 66 | 5.8% |
| Under 5 | 113 | 9.9% |
Best pizza cities by average Barstool score
Cities with at least five One Bite reviews, ranked by average score:
- New Orleans, LA — 7.97 average over 9 reviews
- New Haven, CT — 7.84 average over 10 reviews
- San Francisco, CA — 7.80 average over 14 reviews
- Brooklyn, NY — 7.75 average over 70 reviews
- Staten Island, NY — 7.72 average over 17 reviews
- Scottsdale, AZ — 7.70 average over 7 reviews
- East Haven, CT — 7.70 average over 5 reviews
- Manhattan, NY — 7.68 average over 6 reviews
- Astoria, NY — 7.66 average over 5 reviews
- Nashville, TN — 7.61 average over 12 reviews
The most-reviewed cities
- New York, NY — 360 reviews, average 6.36
- Chicago, IL — 85 reviews, average 7.12
- Brooklyn, NY — 70 reviews, average 7.75
- Miami, FL — 50 reviews, average 7.19
- Philadelphia, PA — 46 reviews, average 7.17
- Miami Beach, FL — 27 reviews, average 6.86
- Boston, MA — 24 reviews, average 7.05
- Las Vegas, NV — 23 reviews, average 5.47
- Boca Raton, FL — 21 reviews, average 7.54
- Hoboken, NJ — 19 reviews, average 7.39
Best pizza states by average score
States with at least five reviews:
- Arizona — 7.70 across 26 reviews
- Connecticut — 7.64 across 86 reviews
- Louisiana — 7.50 across 18 reviews
- New Jersey — 7.47 across 222 reviews
- Tennessee — 7.32 across 24 reviews
- Pennsylvania — 7.18 across 103 reviews
- Illinois — 7.12 across 110 reviews
- Massachusetts — 7.04 across 179 reviews
- Rhode Island — 6.96 across 19 reviews
- Florida — 6.91 across 196 reviews
Barstool reviews by pizza style
Most reviews are a classic New York-style cheese slice, but the series covers every regional style. Average scores by style:
- New York-Style: 1656 reviews, average 6.74
- Tavern-Style Thin Crust: 95 reviews, average 7.20
- Coal-Fired: 42 reviews, average 7.64
- New Haven Apizza: 41 reviews, average 7.98
- Wood-Fired & Brick Oven: 36 reviews, average 7.44
- Sicilian & Grandma: 33 reviews, average 7.29
- Bar Pie: 33 reviews, average 8.21
- Detroit-Style: 25 reviews, average 7.34
- Neapolitan: 21 reviews, average 6.84
- Roman Pizza: 19 reviews, average 6.83
- Grilled Pizza: 12 reviews, average 6.08
- Trenton Tomato Pie: 9 reviews, average 7.92
- Old Forge-Style: 9 reviews, average 7.43
- Chicago Deep Dish: 7 reviews, average 7.40
- Ohio Valley-Style: 7 reviews, average 7.03
- St. Louis-Style: 3 reviews, average 6.20
Style labels are ours, based on each pizzeria's name, oven and regional tradition, with editor checks on the best-known spots.
Watch the reviews
Barstool posts every review on barstoolsports.com and its social channels, and the One Bite app keeps them all on a map. Each pizzeria page in our directory links straight to its Barstool video when we have it. Start with the full rankings or the top-scoring pizzeria.
Barstool pizza review FAQ
What are Barstool pizza reviews?
Barstool pizza reviews are short videos from Barstool Sports in which founder Dave Portnoy takes one bite of a plain slice and scores the pizzeria out of 10. Barstool calls the series One Bite.
Which city has the best One Bite scores?
Among cities with at least five reviews, New Orleans, LA has the highest average at 7.97.
What share of pizzerias score an 8 or higher?
16.4% of scored pizzerias in our data reached 8.0 or higher.