Frozen · 66 pizzas

Frozen pizza rankings

Dave Portnoy doesn't only review pizzerias. These are his One Bite scores for grocery-store frozen pizzas, best to worst. Average: 5.96.

Frozen pizza One Bite scores
RankFrozen pizzaScore
#1Zuppardi's8.8
#2Detroit Style Pizza8.5
#3Lou Malnati's8.4
#3Sam's Coal Fired8.4
#5Antico Casa8.3
#6Carlo's Pizza8.1
#6Wegmans8.1
#6Angelo Pizza8.1
#9Massa Pizza Co7.8
#10Table 877.7
#10Flourchild Pizza7.7
#10Flipper's Bakery7.7
#13Columbia Inn7.4
#13Newman's Own7.4
#15Giordano's7.3
#15Portobello's7.3
#17Cape Cod Cafe7.2
#17Eat Pizza7.2
#17WisePies7.2
#20Brickn Fire7.1
#20American FB7.1
#20Paesan's7.1
#20Stouffer's7.1
#24Tree Tavern7.0
#25Bagel Bites6.9
#25Roberto's6.9
#25So Dough-Licious6.9
#28Rhombus Guys6.8
#29Mother Kelly's6.7
#30Nardone Bros6.6
#31Lottza Motzza6.5
#32Amy's6.4
#32Mama Celeste6.4
#32Pizano's6.4
#35Lenny's6.3
#36Red Baron6.2
#37Carmine's6.1
#38Motor City5.9
#38Taft's5.9
#40Pagliai's5.8
#41Freschetta5.7
#41Giacobbino's5.7
#43Vito & Nicks5.6
#43Screamin' Sicilian5.6
#45Heggies5.4
#46Mickey's Pocket5.3
#46Sammy's5.3
#48Trader Joe's5.2
#49Wild Mike's5.1
#49Arthur Ave5.1
#51Papa Gino's4.9
#51Home Run Inn4.9
#51Giovanni's4.9
#54Spinato's4.8
#55Palermo's4.7
#56California Pizza Kitchen4.2
#57Uno Pizzeria4.1
#58Ellio's3.1
#58Tombstone3.1
#60Pep's2.9
#61DiGiorno2.8
#62Mystic Pizza2.2
#62Imo's Pizza2.2
#62Crazy Italian2.2
#65Hot Pockets1.7
#66Jack's0.08

Want to cook one better at home? Read our frozen pizza guide. Looking for fresh pies? See the pizzeria rankings.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best frozen pizza according to Dave Portnoy?

Zuppardi's tops the list at 8.8, followed by Detroit Style Pizza (8.5) and Lou Malnati's (8.4).

What is the worst frozen pizza Dave Portnoy has reviewed?

Jack's sits at the bottom with 0.08.

How many frozen pizzas has Dave Portnoy reviewed?

We list 66 frozen pizza reviews with an average score of 5.96.

Are frozen pizzas scored the same way as pizzerias?

Yes — same 0 to 10 scale and the same one-bite ritual, usually baked at home. Frozen pizzas tend to score lower than pizzerias, so a frozen pie in the 7s is a strong result.