Guide
How One Bite pizza scores work
One slice, one bite, one number from 0 to 10. Here's how to read Dave Portnoy's scores and where the points get docked.
The scale, tier by tier
These bands are our reading of how scores land across 1,143 reviews, not an official Barstool rubric.
| Score | Tier | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.0 – 10 | Elite | All-time great. A handful of pizzerias in the whole series. | Monte's Restaurant (10.0) |
| 8.0 – 8.9 | Great | Worth a trip. The kind of score that brings lines out the door. | Conte's Pizza (8.9) |
| 7.0 – 7.9 | Solid | A good slice you’d be happy to have around the corner. | Eagle Brook Saloon (7.9) |
| 6.0 – 6.9 | Decent | Fine, forgettable. Something’s off — floppy, bland or bready. | Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza (6.9) |
| 4.0 – 5.9 | Below average | Real problems with the crust, sauce or cheese. | NYC Pizza (5.9) |
| Under 4 | Avoid | Rare, and usually memorable for the wrong reasons. | Libretto's Pizzeria (3.9) |
Where the points get docked
Since every review is the same plain cheese slice, the deductions come up again and again:
- Undercarriage: pale, wet or burnt bottoms are the most common complaint. Even, leopard-spotted char is the goal.
- Flop: a slice that droops when you hold it by the crust loses structure points.
- Crust: too bready, too dense, cracker-dry or underbaked at the rim.
- Sauce: too sweet, too sparse or watery enough to make the slice soggy.
- Cheese: rubbery, sliding off in one sheet, or pooling orange grease.
- Reheat: a slice that's been sitting and gets reheated badly can lose a point on its own.
Every pizzeria page in our directory has a "Points docked" box showing how far it landed from a perfect 10, plus the specific deductions where we've logged them.
Why style matters
A one-bite cheese slice suits some styles better than others. A thin, crisp New York or New Haven slice shows everything in one bite; a deep dish or a loaded Detroit square is harder to judge that way. Our pizza style guides explain what each style is supposed to be, and every style page ranks Dave Portnoy's highest-scoring pizzerias in that style.
Dave's score vs. the community score
In the One Bite app, fans add their own ratings, so a pizzeria shows Dave's number next to a community average. The two often disagree, which is half the fun.
Frequently asked questions
What is the One Bite scoring scale?
Dave Portnoy scores each pizzeria from 0 to 10, to one decimal place, after a single bite of a plain cheese slice.
What does "points docked" mean?
It is fan shorthand for what pulled a score down from 10 — a pale undercarriage, too much flop, a bready crust, sweet sauce or greasy cheese.
Why are most scores between 6 and 8?
Because that’s where most pizza is. The average in our data is 6.85, so the useful differences live in tenths of a point.
Is there a community score?
Yes. In the official One Bite app, fans can post their own scores, so each pizzeria shows both Dave’s score and a community average.