East Rutherford, New Jersey

Best pizza in East Rutherford: Dave Portnoy's One Bite reviews

3 One Bite reviews in East Rutherford, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. The top slice in town is The New Park Tavern at 7.8; the East Rutherford average is 6.40 across 3 scored reviews (the New Jersey average is 7.47).

Styles reviewed here: Tavern-Style Thin Crust (1), Wood-Fired & Brick Oven (1), New York-Style (1). Use the chips to filter.

  1. #1 7.8 The New Park Tavern Tavern
  2. #2 7.2 Vesta Wood Fired Pizza & Bar Wood-fired
  3. #3 4.2 Meadowlands Racing and Entertainment New York

More New Jersey pizza cities

All 222 One Bite reviews in New Jersey →