One Bite pizza review · Indianapolis, IN
Goodfellas Pizzeria
Dave Portnoy gave Goodfellas Pizzeria a 8.1 on his Barstool Sports One Bite review — Great territory, ranked #117 of 1,143 scored pizzerias.
- Dave Portnoy score
- 8.1 / 10
- Overall rank
- #117 of 1,143
- Rank in Indiana
- #1 of 12
- Rank in Indianapolis
- #1 of 6
- Pizza style
- New York-Style
- Rank among New York pizzerias
- #84 of 930
- Review date
- September 27, 2017
- Location
- Indianapolis, Indiana
Points docked
1.9 points short of a perfect 10.
We haven't logged the specific deductions for this review yet. In One Bite reviews, points usually come off for a pale or soggy undercarriage, too much flop, a crust that's bready or burnt, sauce that's too sweet or too thin, and cheese that slides or pools grease. The video has the full breakdown.
How it compares
- 1.92 above the Indiana average (6.18)
- 1.68 above the Indianapolis average (6.42)
- 1.36 above the New York-Style average (6.74)
Most One Bite reviews are a plain cheese slice in the New York tradition, so that is our default label until an editor confirms otherwise. Read about New York-Style pizza.
More One Bite reviews in Indianapolis
- #1 7.4 Giorgio's Pizza New York
- #2 7.1 Bryne's Grilled Pizza Grilled
- #3 6.7 Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta New York
- #4 5.1 Bazbeaux Pizza New York
- #5 4.1 Napolese Pizzeria New York
- TBD Ale Emporium New York
- TBD Byrne's Grilled Pizza Grilled
- TBD Futuro New York
- TBD King Dough New York
- TBD Pizza King Station New York
- TBD Sam's Square Pie Sicilian/Grandma
Other New York-Style pizza in Indiana
Top-rated pizza in Indiana
- Brozinni Pizzeria at SpeedwaySpeedway · 7.4
- Giorgio's PizzaIndianapolis · 7.4
- Bryne's Grilled PizzaIndianapolis · 7.1
- Pasquale's Pizza & PastaIndianapolis · 6.7
- Strong's Brick Oven PizzeriaLawrenceburg · 6.7
- Eric Gordon's Greek's PizzeriaBloomington · 6.4
- Mother Bear's Pizza CampusBloomington · 6.1
- Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & PubWestfield · 5.9
Every One Bite review in Indiana →
Scores are Dave Portnoy's, as published by Barstool Sports and compiled from public sources. Restaurants change; check hours and current reviews before you go. One Bite Pizza Reviews is an unofficial fan site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy or the One Bite app. Scores are reported from public sources; names and trademarks belong to their owners.