The full list

One Bite pizza rankings

Every pizzeria Dave Portnoy has reviewed for Barstool Sports' One Bite series, ranked by score — plus his frozen pizza reviews. Search by name or town, filter by pizza style, or switch between fresh and frozen.

  1. #1 10.0 Monte's RestaurantLynn, MA New York
  2. #2 9.4 DeLucia's Brick Oven PizzaRaritan, NJ Wood-fired
  3. #2 9.4 Di Fara PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  4. #2 9.4 Frank Pepe Pizzeria NapoletanaChestnut Hill, MA New Haven
  5. #5 9.3 Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  6. #5 9.3 John's of Bleecker StreetNew York, NY Coal oven
  7. #5 9.3 Lazzara's PizzaNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  8. #5 9.3 LucaliBrooklyn, NY New York
  9. #5 9.3 Luigi's PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  10. #5 9.3 Oath PizzaNantucket, MA New York
  11. #11 9.2 CeresNew York, NY New York
  12. #11 9.2 De Lorenzo's Tomato PiesRobbinsville, NJ Tomato pie
  13. #11 9.2 Halftime PizzaBoston, MA New York
  14. #11 9.2 Rosie's Subs and PizzaBraintree, MA Bar pie
  15. #11 9.2 Sally's ApizzaNew Haven, CT New Haven
  16. #16 9.1 Angelo's PizzeriaPhiladelphia, PA New York
  17. #16 9.1 Best PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  18. #16 9.1 Johnny's PizzeriaMount Vernon, NY New York
  19. #16 9.1 Regina PizzeriaBoston, MA Wood-fired
  20. #16 9.1 Sauce PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  21. #16 9.1 The Little RendezvousMeriden, CT New York
  22. #22 9.0 Denino's Greenwich VillageNew York, NY New York
  23. #22 9.0 Town Spa PizzaStoughton, MA Bar pie
  24. #24 8.9 Brooklyn Square PizzaJackson, NJ Sicilian/Grandma
  25. #24 8.9 Calabria Pizzeria & RestaurantLivingston, NJ New York
  26. #24 8.9 Conte's PizzaPrinceton, NJ New York
  27. #24 8.9 Mister O1- South BeachMiami Beach, FL New York
  28. #24 8.9 Ralph's PizzeriaNutley, NJ New York
  29. #29 8.8 Angeloni's Restaurant & PizzeriaCaldwell, NJ New York
  30. #29 8.8 Federici's Family RestaurantFreehold, NJ New York
  31. #29 8.8 Modern ApizzaNew Haven, CT New Haven
  32. #29 8.8 Nancy's Towne HouseRahway, NJ New York
  33. #29 8.8 Pino's PizzaBrighton, MA New York
  34. #29 8.8 Zuppardi'sFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  35. #35 8.7 Columbia Inn RestaurantMontville, NJ New York
  36. #35 8.7 F & F PizzeriaBrooklyn, NY New York
  37. #35 8.7 Fredi The PizzaManMelvindale, MI New York
  38. #35 8.7 Ignazio'sBrooklyn, NY New York
  39. #35 8.7 Sorrento'sLong Beach, NY New York
  40. #40 8.6 Joe & Pat's PizzeriaStaten Island, NY New York
  41. #40 8.6 Nove Italian RestaurantGansevoort, NY New York
  42. #40 8.6 Nunzio's PizzeriaLong Branch, NJ New York
  43. #40 8.6 Papa's Tomato PiesRobbinsville, NJ Tomato pie
  44. #40 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  45. #40 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  46. #40 8.6 Pi PizzeriaNantucket, MA New York
  47. #40 8.6 Prince Street PizzaNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  48. #40 8.6 Rizzo's Fine PizzaNew York, NY New York
  49. #40 8.6 Roseland ApizzaDerby, CT New Haven
  50. #40 8.6 Tenth Street Pasta & PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  51. #40 8.6 Tommy's PizzaBronx, NY New York
  52. #40 8.6 Umberto's Pizzeria & RestaurantNew Hyde Park, NY New York
  53. #40 8.6 Williamsburg PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  54. #54 8.5 Brooklyn Pizza MastersNew York, NY New York
  55. #54 8.5 Cape Cod CafeBrockton, MA Bar pie
  56. #54 8.5 Detroit Style PizzaFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  57. #54 8.5 Double ZeroNew York, NY New York
  58. #54 8.5 Frank Pepe Pizzeria NapoletanaNew Haven, CT New Haven
  59. #54 8.5 Fuoco ApizzaCheshire, CT New Haven
  60. #54 8.5 Joe's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  61. #54 8.5 John & Maria's PizzeriaEast Haven, CT New Haven
  62. #54 8.5 Lil' Frankie'sNew York, NY New York
  63. #54 8.5 Perfect PizzaNorth Bergen, NJ New York
  64. #54 8.5 Rosie's PizzaPoint Pleasant Beach, NJ New York
  65. #54 8.5 Tony's PlaceWest Roxbury, MA New York
  66. #66 8.4 Best Pizza & Dive BarAmagansett, NY New York
  67. #66 8.4 Colony GrillStamford, CT Bar pie
  68. #66 8.4 Giordano'sChicago, IL Deep dish
  69. #66 8.4 Joe & Pat's PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  70. #66 8.4 John's of Times SquareNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  71. #66 8.4 Lou Malnati'sFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  72. #66 8.4 Luigi's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  73. #66 8.4 Nick's PizzaForest Hills, NY Coal oven
  74. #66 8.4 Picciotto NYCNew York, NY New York
  75. #66 8.4 Pizza SamJackson Heights, NY New York
  76. #66 8.4 Saba's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  77. #66 8.4 Sam's Coal FiredFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  78. #66 8.4 Trattoria L'incontroAstoria, NY New York
  79. #66 8.4 Vinny VincenzNew York, NY New York
  80. #80 8.3 Antico CasaFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  81. #80 8.3 Antico PizzaAtlanta, GA New York
  82. #80 8.3 Black Sheep Pizza - MinneapolisMinneapolis, MN New York
  83. #80 8.3 Christo's Restaurant & BarWallingford, CT New Haven
  84. #80 8.3 Forbidden PizzaNew Orleans, LA New York
  85. #80 8.3 GatoNew York, NY New York
  86. #80 8.3 Joe's PizzaSanta Monica, CA New York
  87. #80 8.3 Pizzeria 'LucciBelmar, NJ New York
  88. #80 8.3 Santillo's Brick Oven PizzaElizabeth, NJ Wood-fired
  89. #80 8.3 SauceNew York, NY New York
  90. #80 8.3 Speedy RomeoNew York, NY New York
  91. #80 8.3 Surly BrewingMinneapolis, MN New York
  92. #80 8.3 Vic's Italian RestaurantBradley Beach, NJ New York
  93. #93 8.2 Bianchi's PizzaRevere, MA New York
  94. #93 8.2 Brick Oven Pizza 33New York, NY Wood-fired
  95. #93 8.2 Brunetti PizzaNew York, NY New York
  96. #93 8.2 Carpanzano'sGuilford, CT New York
  97. #93 8.2 Cello's PizzeriaManhattan, NY New York
  98. #93 8.2 Circles and SquaresPhiladelphia, PA Sicilian/Grandma
  99. #93 8.2 Del Ponte's Coal Fired PizzaBradley Beach, NJ Coal oven
  100. #93 8.2 Eleventh Street PizzaMiami, FL New York
  101. #93 8.2 Florina Pizzeria & PaninotecaBoston, MA New York
  102. #93 8.2 Grand Pizza ShorelineClinton, CT New York
  103. #93 8.2 Grigg Street PizzaGreenwich, CT New York
  104. #93 8.2 Il Supremo PizzaMetairie, LA New York
  105. #93 8.2 Lou Malnati's PizzeriaChicago, IL Deep dish
  106. #93 8.2 Marc's Artisanal PizzeriaMiami Beach, FL New York
  107. #93 8.2 Merilu Pizza Al MetroNew York, NY New York
  108. #93 8.2 Numero 28 Pizzeria - West VillageNew York, NY New York
  109. #93 8.2 NY Pizza SupremaNew York, NY New York
  110. #93 8.2 PaciDough's Pizza JointToms River, NJ New York
  111. #93 8.2 Patsy's Tavern & RestaurantPaterson, NJ Tavern
  112. #93 8.2 Pizza TimeBrooklyn, NY New York
  113. #93 8.2 Pope's Italian RestaurantSaratoga Springs, NY New York
  114. #93 8.2 Riko's PizzaStamford, CT New York
  115. #93 8.2 Rocco's Pizza JointNew York, NY New York
  116. #93 8.2 Saluggi'sNew York, NY New York
  117. #93 8.2 Santarpio's PizzaBoston, MA New York
  118. #93 8.2 Stromboli PizzaNew York, NY New York
  119. #93 8.2 The LongshoremanNew York, NY New York
  120. #93 8.2 Vito's PizzaSanta Monica, CA New York
  121. #93 8.2 Zuppardi's ApizzaWest Haven, CT New Haven
  122. #122 8.1 310 Bowery BarNew York, NY New York
  123. #122 8.1 Amore PizzeriaFlushing, NY New York
  124. #122 8.1 Angelo PizzaFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  125. #122 8.1 Angelo's PizzaWilkes Barre, PA New York
  126. #122 8.1 Bar BucceMiami, FL New York
  127. #122 8.1 Basile's PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  128. #122 8.1 Bronx PizzaSan Diego, CA New York
  129. #122 8.1 Cafe Daniello'sNew York, NY New York
  130. #122 8.1 Caputo's PizzeriaSaratoga Springs, NY New York
  131. #122 8.1 Carlo's PizzaFrozen pizza · grocery store Frozen
  132. #122 8.1 Cesare's RistoranteBristol, PA New York
  133. #122 8.1 Champion PizzaNew York, NY New York
  134. #122 8.1 Corner SquareBayonne, NJ Sicilian/Grandma
  135. #122 8.1 Denino's Pizzeria TavernStaten Island, NY Tavern
  136. #122 8.1 Detroit Style Pizza CoSt Clair Shores, MI Detroit
  137. #122 8.1 Domenick & Pia PizzeriaWaterbury, CT New York
  138. #122 8.1 Eda's PizzeriaPhiladelphia, PA New York
  139. #122 8.1 Emelio's RestaurantColumbus, OH New York
  140. #122 8.1 Famous Ben's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  141. #122 8.1 Flour Pizzeria & CafeLos Angeles, CA New York
  142. #122 8.1 Francesco's PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  143. #122 8.1 Freddie & Pepper'sNew York, NY New York
  144. #122 8.1 Gerry's PizzeriaWilkes Barre, PA New York
  145. #122 8.1 Goodfellas PizzeriaIndianapolis, IN New York
  146. #122 8.1 HeritageFort Lauderdale, FL New York
  147. #122 8.1 Jiannetto's Pizza TruckNew York, NY New York
  148. #122 8.1 King Umberto's of ElmontElmont, NY New York
  149. #122 8.1 L'Arte Della Pizza BrooklynBrooklyn, NY New York
  150. #122 8.1 Leo's HideoutSan Antonio, TX New York

"TBD" means Barstool has posted the review video but the score isn't in our data yet. 1,143 of 2,048 pizzerias have a published score.