New York, New York

Best pizza in New York: Dave Portnoy's One Bite reviews

360 One Bite reviews in New York, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. The top slice in town is Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria at 9.3; the New York average is 6.36 across 336 scored reviews (the New York average is 6.70).

Styles reviewed here: New York-Style (326), Coal-Fired (9), Sicilian & Grandma (9), Neapolitan (7), Wood-Fired & Brick Oven (6), Detroit-Style (2), Roman Pizza (1). Use the chips to filter.

  1. #1 9.3 Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria Coal oven
  2. #1 9.3 John's of Bleecker Street Coal oven
  3. #1 9.3 Lazzara's Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
  4. #4 9.2 Ceres New York
  5. #5 9.1 Sauce Pizzeria New York
  6. #6 9.0 Denino's Greenwich Village New York
  7. #7 8.6 Patsy's Pizzeria Coal oven
  8. #7 8.6 Patsy's Pizzeria Coal oven
  9. #7 8.6 Prince Street Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
  10. #7 8.6 Rizzo's Fine Pizza New York
  11. #11 8.5 Brooklyn Pizza Masters New York
  12. #11 8.5 Double Zero New York
  13. #11 8.5 Joe's Pizza New York
  14. #11 8.5 Lil' Frankie's New York
  15. #15 8.4 Joe & Pat's Pizzeria New York
  16. #15 8.4 John's of Times Square Sicilian/Grandma
  17. #15 8.4 Luigi's Pizza New York
  18. #15 8.4 Picciotto NYC New York
  19. #15 8.4 Saba's Pizza New York
  20. #15 8.4 Vinny Vincenz New York
  21. #21 8.3 Gato New York
  22. #21 8.3 Sauce New York
  23. #21 8.3 Speedy Romeo New York
  24. #24 8.2 Brick Oven Pizza 33 Wood-fired
  25. #24 8.2 Brunetti Pizza New York
  26. #24 8.2 Merilu Pizza Al Metro New York
  27. #24 8.2 Numero 28 Pizzeria - West Village New York
  28. #24 8.2 NY Pizza Suprema New York
  29. #24 8.2 Rocco's Pizza Joint New York
  30. #24 8.2 Saluggi's New York
  31. #24 8.2 Stromboli Pizza New York
  32. #24 8.2 The Longshoreman New York
  33. #33 8.1 310 Bowery Bar New York
  34. #33 8.1 Cafe Daniello's New York
  35. #33 8.1 Champion Pizza New York
  36. #33 8.1 Famous Ben's Pizza New York
  37. #33 8.1 Francesco's Pizzeria New York
  38. #33 8.1 Freddie & Pepper's New York
  39. #33 8.1 Jiannetto's Pizza Truck New York
  40. #33 8.1 Lombardi's pizza Coal oven
  41. #33 8.1 Luigi's Gourmet Grill New York
  42. #33 8.1 Neapolitan Express Neapolitan
  43. #33 8.1 Nicoletta Pizzeria New York
  44. #33 8.1 Pisa Pizza New York
  45. #33 8.1 PizzArte New York
  46. #33 8.1 Rubirosa New York
  47. #33 8.1 Sacco Pizza New York
  48. #33 8.1 Sal's Little Italy New York
  49. #49 8.0 East Village Pizza New York
  50. #49 8.0 La Margarita Pizza New York
  51. #51 7.9 Artichoke Basille's Pizza New York
  52. #51 7.9 Arturo's Coal oven
  53. #51 7.9 Fresco By Scotto New York
  54. #51 7.9 Il Mattone West Village New York
  55. #51 7.9 Made In New York Pizza New York
  56. #51 7.9 Manhattan Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
  57. #51 7.9 Patrizia's Pizza and Pasta New York
  58. #51 7.9 Rock Pizza Scissors New York
  59. #51 7.9 Sofia Pizza Shoppe New York
  60. #60 7.8 Adoro Lei New York
  61. #60 7.8 Artichoke Basille's Pizza New York
  62. #60 7.8 Botanica Bar New York
  63. #60 7.8 Emmett's New York
  64. #60 7.8 Frank's Trattoria New York
  65. #60 7.8 Joe's Pizza New York
  66. #60 7.8 La Bellezza New York
  67. #60 7.8 Peperino New York
  68. #60 7.8 Pizza Da Solo New York
  69. #60 7.8 Rivoli Pizza New York
  70. #60 7.8 Salvo's Pizzabar New York
  71. #60 7.8 Serafina Meatpacking New York
  72. #60 7.8 Zazzy's Pizza New York
  73. #73 7.7 3 Giovani New York
  74. #73 7.7 Ciao Vineria con Cucina New York
  75. #73 7.7 Harry's Italian New York
  76. #73 7.7 Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria New York
  77. #73 7.7 Italian Village Pizzeria New York
  78. #73 7.7 Mike's Pizza New York
  79. #73 7.7 Pepe Giallo New York
  80. #73 7.7 Phil's Pizza New York
  81. #73 7.7 Scarr's Pizza New York
  82. #73 7.7 Sfila Pizza New York
  83. #73 7.7 Song E Napule Neapolitan
  84. #73 7.7 Vezzo New York
  85. #85 7.6 Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet New York
  86. #85 7.6 Frank & Danny's Pizzeria New York
  87. #85 7.6 Motorino New York
  88. #85 7.6 Pizza Collective New York
  89. #85 7.6 Village Square Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
  90. #90 7.5 Pop's Pizzas New York
  91. #90 7.5 Royal Pizza New York
  92. #92 7.4 Death By Pizza New York
  93. #92 7.4 Enzo Claudio Pizzeria New York
  94. #92 7.4 Famous Famiglia Pizzeria New York
  95. #92 7.4 Filaga Pizzeria New York
  96. #92 7.4 Gnocco New York
  97. #92 7.4 Il Piccolo Bufalo New York
  98. #92 7.4 Jet's Pizza Detroit
  99. #92 7.4 Justino's Pizzeria New York
  100. #92 7.4 Margherita NYC New York
  101. #92 7.4 Marinara Pizza New York
  102. #92 7.4 Moustache Pitza New York
  103. #92 7.4 Nolita Pizza New York
  104. #92 7.4 Prova Pizzabar New York
  105. #92 7.4 Resca New York
  106. #92 7.4 Rosemary's Pizza New York
  107. #92 7.4 Stage Door Pizza New York
  108. #92 7.4 The Woodstock New York
  109. #92 7.4 Upside Pizza New York
  110. #92 7.4 Vito's Slices and Ices New York
  111. #111 7.3 Baker's Pizza New York
  112. #111 7.3 Campania Coal Fired Pizza Coal oven
  113. #111 7.3 Gigino Trattoria New York
  114. #111 7.3 Harry's Italian Pizza Bar New York
  115. #111 7.3 Inattesco Pizzabar New York
  116. #111 7.3 Marinara Pizza New York
  117. #111 7.3 Pasquale Jones New York
  118. #111 7.3 Pie Pie Pizza New York
  119. #111 7.3 Sauce & Barrel New York
  120. #111 7.3 Sauce & Bread New York
  121. #111 7.3 Serafina Broadway New York
  122. #111 7.3 Teresa's Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe Wood-fired
  123. #111 7.3 Unregular Pizza New York
  124. #124 7.2 Bella Blu New York
  125. #124 7.2 Cafe Fiorello New York
  126. #124 7.2 Company New York
  127. #124 7.2 Corner Slice New York
  128. #124 7.2 Dona Bella Pizza New York
  129. #124 7.2 Eleven B New York
  130. #124 7.2 Emily - West Village New York
  131. #124 7.2 Manero's Pizza New York
  132. #124 7.2 Pizza Pete's New York
  133. #124 7.2 Proto's Pizza New York
  134. #124 7.2 Sal & Carmine's Pizza New York
  135. #135 7.1 BarDough New York
  136. #135 7.1 Capizzi New York
  137. #135 7.1 City Pizza New York
  138. #135 7.1 Cucina Bene New York
  139. #135 7.1 Emporio New York
  140. #135 7.1 Feroce Ristorante New York
  141. #135 7.1 IL Brigante New York
  142. #135 7.1 Il Corallo Trattoria New York
  143. #135 7.1 Kiss My Slice New York
  144. #135 7.1 La Bellezza Pizza New York
  145. #135 7.1 La Pizza Fresca Ristorante New York
  146. #135 7.1 Lions & Tigers & Squares Detroit Pizza Detroit
  147. #135 7.1 Majestic Pizza New York
  148. #135 7.1 New York Sal's Pizza New York
  149. #135 7.1 Re Sette New York
  150. #135 7.1 Sorbillo Pizzeria New York
  151. #135 7.1 The Bread Factory New York
  152. #135 7.1 Uncle Mario's Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
  153. #135 7.1 Villa Pizza New York
  154. #135 7.1 Vinnie's Pizzeria New York
  155. #135 7.1 Zia Maria-Chelsea New York
  156. #156 7.0 Fiore's Pizza New York
  157. #157 6.9 10th Avenue Pizza & Cafe New York
  158. #157 6.9 Biga Contemporary Pizza New York
  159. #157 6.9 Bleecker Street Pizza New York
  160. #157 6.9 Famous Calabria New York
  161. #157 6.9 Girello New York
  162. #157 6.9 Gotham Pizza New York
  163. #157 6.9 Joe G Pizza & Restaurant New York
  164. #157 6.9 Mama's Pizzeria New York
  165. #157 6.9 Mariella Pizza New York
  166. #157 6.9 Nino's 46 New York
  167. #157 6.9 Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo's New York
  168. #157 6.9 Prova Pizzabar New York
  169. #157 6.9 Sotto 13 New York
  170. #157 6.9 Village Pizza New York
  171. #171 6.8 Aperitivo Pizza Bar New York
  172. #171 6.8 Artistic Pizza New York
  173. #171 6.8 Bricco Ristorante Italiano New York
  174. #171 6.8 Casabianca Pizzeria New York
  175. #171 6.8 Claudio Pizzeria New York
  176. #171 6.8 Garlic New York Pizza Bar New York
  177. #171 6.8 J's Pizza New York
  178. #171 6.8 La Trattoria New York
  179. #171 6.8 MAMA'S TOO! Sicilian/Grandma
  180. #171 6.8 Melani Pizzeria New York
  181. #171 6.8 Nizza New York
  182. #171 6.8 Pasta by Hudson New York
  183. #171 6.8 Posto New York
  184. #171 6.8 SIMÒ PIZZA New York
  185. #171 6.8 Starbucks Reserve Roastery New York
  186. #186 6.7 Buchetta Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
  187. #186 6.7 John & Tony's New York
  188. #186 6.7 La Mia Pizza New York
  189. #186 6.7 Primavera Pizza & Pasta New York
  190. #186 6.7 Tre Sorelle New York
  191. #186 6.7 Via Trenta Pizzoteca New York
  192. #192 6.6 Cassiano's Pizza New York
  193. #192 6.6 Muzzarella Pizza New York
  194. #192 6.6 Nick's Pizza Coal oven
  195. #192 6.6 Pizza By Certé New York
  196. #192 6.6 Pizza Rollio New York
  197. #192 6.6 Ribalta Mo' Neapolitan
  198. #192 6.6 Two Boots West Village New York
  199. #199 6.5 Bond 45 New York
  200. #199 6.5 Oath Pizza - East 67th Street New York

More New York pizza cities

All 636 One Bite reviews in New York →