One Bite pizza review · New York, NY
Wild
Dave Portnoy gave Wild a 4.1 on his Barstool Sports One Bite review — Below average territory, ranked #1067 of 1,143 scored pizzerias.
- Dave Portnoy score
- 4.1 / 10
- Overall rank
- #1067 of 1,143
- Rank in New York
- #444 of 483
- Rank in New York
- #297 of 336
- Pizza style
- New York-Style
- Rank among New York pizzerias
- #857 of 930
- Review date
- July 12, 2017
Points docked
5.9 points short of a perfect 10.
We haven't logged the specific deductions for this review yet. In One Bite reviews, points usually come off for a pale or soggy undercarriage, too much flop, a crust that's bready or burnt, sauce that's too sweet or too thin, and cheese that slides or pools grease. The video has the full breakdown.
How it compares
- 2.60 below the New York average (6.70)
- 2.26 below the New York average (6.36)
- 2.64 below the New York-Style average (6.74)
Most One Bite reviews are a plain cheese slice in the New York tradition, so that is our default label until an editor confirms otherwise. Read about New York-Style pizza.
More One Bite reviews in New York
- #1 9.3 Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria Coal oven
- #1 9.3 John's of Bleecker Street Coal oven
- #1 9.3 Lazzara's Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #4 9.2 Ceres New York
- #5 9.1 Sauce Pizzeria New York
- #6 9.0 Denino's Greenwich Village New York
- #7 8.6 Patsy's Pizzeria Coal oven
- #7 8.6 Patsy's Pizzeria Coal oven
- #7 8.6 Prince Street Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #7 8.6 Rizzo's Fine Pizza New York
- #11 8.5 Brooklyn Pizza Masters New York
- #11 8.5 Double Zero New York
- #11 8.5 Joe's Pizza New York
- #11 8.5 Lil' Frankie's New York
- #15 8.4 Joe & Pat's Pizzeria New York
- #15 8.4 John's of Times Square Sicilian/Grandma
- #15 8.4 Luigi's Pizza New York
- #15 8.4 Picciotto NYC New York
- #15 8.4 Saba's Pizza New York
- #15 8.4 Vinny Vincenz New York
- #21 8.3 Gato New York
- #21 8.3 Sauce New York
- #21 8.3 Speedy Romeo New York
- #24 8.2 Brick Oven Pizza 33 Wood-fired
- #24 8.2 Brunetti Pizza New York
- #24 8.2 Merilu Pizza Al Metro New York
- #24 8.2 Numero 28 Pizzeria - West Village New York
- #24 8.2 NY Pizza Suprema New York
- #24 8.2 Rocco's Pizza Joint New York
- #24 8.2 Saluggi's New York
- #24 8.2 Stromboli Pizza New York
- #24 8.2 The Longshoreman New York
- #33 8.1 310 Bowery Bar New York
- #33 8.1 Cafe Daniello's New York
- #33 8.1 Champion Pizza New York
- #33 8.1 Famous Ben's Pizza New York
- #33 8.1 Francesco's Pizzeria New York
- #33 8.1 Freddie & Pepper's New York
- #33 8.1 Jiannetto's Pizza Truck New York
- #33 8.1 Lombardi's pizza Coal oven
- #33 8.1 Luigi's Gourmet Grill New York
- #33 8.1 Neapolitan Express Neapolitan
- #33 8.1 Nicoletta Pizzeria New York
- #33 8.1 Pisa Pizza New York
- #33 8.1 PizzArte New York
- #33 8.1 Rubirosa New York
- #33 8.1 Sacco Pizza New York
- #33 8.1 Sal's Little Italy New York
- #49 8.0 East Village Pizza New York
- #49 8.0 La Margarita Pizza New York
- #51 7.9 Artichoke Basille's Pizza New York
- #51 7.9 Arturo's Coal oven
- #51 7.9 Fresco By Scotto New York
- #51 7.9 Il Mattone West Village New York
- #51 7.9 Made In New York Pizza New York
- #51 7.9 Manhattan Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
- #51 7.9 Patrizia's Pizza and Pasta New York
- #51 7.9 Rock Pizza Scissors New York
- #51 7.9 Sofia Pizza Shoppe New York
- #60 7.8 Adoro Lei New York
- #60 7.8 Artichoke Basille's Pizza New York
- #60 7.8 Botanica Bar New York
- #60 7.8 Emmett's New York
- #60 7.8 Frank's Trattoria New York
- #60 7.8 Joe's Pizza New York
- #60 7.8 La Bellezza New York
- #60 7.8 Peperino New York
- #60 7.8 Pizza Da Solo New York
- #60 7.8 Rivoli Pizza New York
- #60 7.8 Salvo's Pizzabar New York
- #60 7.8 Serafina Meatpacking New York
- #60 7.8 Zazzy's Pizza New York
- #73 7.7 3 Giovani New York
- #73 7.7 Ciao Vineria con Cucina New York
- #73 7.7 Harry's Italian New York
- #73 7.7 Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria New York
- #73 7.7 Italian Village Pizzeria New York
- #73 7.7 Mike's Pizza New York
- #73 7.7 Pepe Giallo New York
- #73 7.7 Phil's Pizza New York
- #73 7.7 Scarr's Pizza New York
- #73 7.7 Sfila Pizza New York
- #73 7.7 Song E Napule Neapolitan
- #73 7.7 Vezzo New York
- #85 7.6 Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet New York
- #85 7.6 Frank & Danny's Pizzeria New York
- #85 7.6 Motorino New York
- #85 7.6 Pizza Collective New York
- #85 7.6 Village Square Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #90 7.5 Pop's Pizzas New York
- #90 7.5 Royal Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Death By Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Enzo Claudio Pizzeria New York
- #92 7.4 Famous Famiglia Pizzeria New York
- #92 7.4 Filaga Pizzeria New York
- #92 7.4 Gnocco New York
- #92 7.4 Il Piccolo Bufalo New York
- #92 7.4 Jet's Pizza Detroit
- #92 7.4 Justino's Pizzeria New York
- #92 7.4 Margherita NYC New York
- #92 7.4 Marinara Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Moustache Pitza New York
- #92 7.4 Nolita Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Prova Pizzabar New York
- #92 7.4 Resca New York
- #92 7.4 Rosemary's Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Stage Door Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 The Woodstock New York
- #92 7.4 Upside Pizza New York
- #92 7.4 Vito's Slices and Ices New York
- #111 7.3 Baker's Pizza New York
- #111 7.3 Campania Coal Fired Pizza Coal oven
- #111 7.3 Gigino Trattoria New York
- #111 7.3 Harry's Italian Pizza Bar New York
- #111 7.3 Inattesco Pizzabar New York
- #111 7.3 Marinara Pizza New York
- #111 7.3 Pasquale Jones New York
- #111 7.3 Pie Pie Pizza New York
- #111 7.3 Sauce & Barrel New York
- #111 7.3 Sauce & Bread New York
- #111 7.3 Serafina Broadway New York
- #111 7.3 Teresa's Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe Wood-fired
- #111 7.3 Unregular Pizza New York
- #124 7.2 Bella Blu New York
- #124 7.2 Cafe Fiorello New York
- #124 7.2 Company New York
- #124 7.2 Corner Slice New York
- #124 7.2 Dona Bella Pizza New York
- #124 7.2 Eleven B New York
- #124 7.2 Emily - West Village New York
- #124 7.2 Manero's Pizza New York
- #124 7.2 Pizza Pete's New York
- #124 7.2 Proto's Pizza New York
- #124 7.2 Sal & Carmine's Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 BarDough New York
- #135 7.1 Capizzi New York
- #135 7.1 City Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 Cucina Bene New York
- #135 7.1 Emporio New York
- #135 7.1 Feroce Ristorante New York
- #135 7.1 IL Brigante New York
- #135 7.1 Il Corallo Trattoria New York
- #135 7.1 Kiss My Slice New York
- #135 7.1 La Bellezza Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 La Pizza Fresca Ristorante New York
- #135 7.1 Lions & Tigers & Squares Detroit Pizza Detroit
- #135 7.1 Majestic Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 New York Sal's Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 Re Sette New York
- #135 7.1 Sorbillo Pizzeria New York
- #135 7.1 The Bread Factory New York
- #135 7.1 Uncle Mario's Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
- #135 7.1 Villa Pizza New York
- #135 7.1 Vinnie's Pizzeria New York
- #135 7.1 Zia Maria-Chelsea New York
- #156 7.0 Fiore's Pizza New York
- #157 6.9 10th Avenue Pizza & Cafe New York
- #157 6.9 Biga Contemporary Pizza New York
- #157 6.9 Bleecker Street Pizza New York
- #157 6.9 Famous Calabria New York
- #157 6.9 Girello New York
- #157 6.9 Gotham Pizza New York
- #157 6.9 Joe G Pizza & Restaurant New York
- #157 6.9 Mama's Pizzeria New York
- #157 6.9 Mariella Pizza New York
- #157 6.9 Nino's 46 New York
- #157 6.9 Ovest Pizzoteca by Luzzo's New York
- #157 6.9 Prova Pizzabar New York
- #157 6.9 Sotto 13 New York
- #157 6.9 Village Pizza New York
- #171 6.8 Aperitivo Pizza Bar New York
- #171 6.8 Artistic Pizza New York
- #171 6.8 Bricco Ristorante Italiano New York
- #171 6.8 Casabianca Pizzeria New York
- #171 6.8 Claudio Pizzeria New York
- #171 6.8 Garlic New York Pizza Bar New York
- #171 6.8 J's Pizza New York
- #171 6.8 La Trattoria New York
- #171 6.8 MAMA'S TOO! Sicilian/Grandma
- #171 6.8 Melani Pizzeria New York
- #171 6.8 Nizza New York
- #171 6.8 Pasta by Hudson New York
- #171 6.8 Posto New York
- #171 6.8 SIMÒ PIZZA New York
- #171 6.8 Starbucks Reserve Roastery New York
- #186 6.7 Buchetta Brick Oven Pizza Wood-fired
- #186 6.7 John & Tony's New York
- #186 6.7 La Mia Pizza New York
- #186 6.7 Primavera Pizza & Pasta New York
- #186 6.7 Tre Sorelle New York
- #186 6.7 Via Trenta Pizzoteca New York
- #192 6.6 Cassiano's Pizza New York
- #192 6.6 Muzzarella Pizza New York
- #192 6.6 Nick's Pizza Coal oven
- #192 6.6 Pizza By Certé New York
- #192 6.6 Pizza Rollio New York
- #192 6.6 Ribalta Mo' Neapolitan
- #192 6.6 Two Boots West Village New York
- #199 6.5 Bond 45 New York
- #199 6.5 Oath Pizza - East 67th Street New York
- #199 6.5 Rivington Pizza New York
- #199 6.5 Square Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #203 6.4 Belmora Pizza & Restaurant New York
- #203 6.4 Claudio Pizzeria New York
- #203 6.4 Don Antonio New York
- #203 6.4 Georgio Pizzeria New York
- #203 6.4 Kesté Pizza & Vino Neapolitan
- #203 6.4 Rocky's Pizza Bar and Restaurant New York
- #203 6.4 Siena Pizza New York
- #203 6.4 Siena Pizza & Cannoli New York
- #203 6.4 Va Bene New York
- #212 6.3 B Side Pizza & Wine Bar New York
- #212 6.3 Il Forno Pizza Wood-fired
- #212 6.3 Kiss My Slice New York
- #212 6.3 Little Italy Pizza New York
- #212 6.3 Margari Pizza New York
- #212 6.3 Old Fashioned Pizza New York
- #212 6.3 Sottosuolo NYC New York
- #212 6.3 Sutton Pizzeria New York
- #212 6.3 Tavola New York
- #221 6.2 Alphonso's Pizzeria & Trattoria New York
- #221 6.2 B & W Deli & Pizzeria New York
- #221 6.2 Black Square Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #221 6.2 Broadway Pizza & Restaurant New York
- #221 6.2 Casa Barilla New York
- #221 6.2 Da Gennaro New York
- #221 6.2 Famous Original Ray's Pizza New York
- #221 6.2 Farinella Bakery Pizza New York
- #221 6.2 Giuseppe's Pizza New York
- #221 6.2 Iggy's Pizzeria New York
- #221 6.2 La Vera Pizzeria & Restaurant New York
- #221 6.2 Lombardi's Pizza Coal oven
- #221 6.2 Rosella's Pizzeria New York
- #221 6.2 Rossetti's Pizza New York
- #221 6.2 Stella's Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Big Al's Chicago Style Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Cheesy Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Deli On Madison New York
- #236 6.1 Little Italy Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Panera Bread New York
- #236 6.1 Panera Bread New York
- #236 6.1 Percy's Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 PQR New York
- #236 6.1 Radio City Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Solo Pizza New York
- #236 6.1 Whole Foods Market New York
- #247 5.9 Benvenuti Pizzeria New York
- #247 5.9 Chelsea Pizza 23 New York
- #247 5.9 Healthy Choice Gourmet Deli & Pizza New York
- #247 5.9 Joey Pepperoni's Pizza New York
- #247 5.9 Little Gio's Pizza New York
- #247 5.9 NYC Pizza New York
- #247 5.9 Pranzo Pizza & Pasta New York
- #247 5.9 Underground Pizza New York
- #255 5.8 Bella Vita Pizzeria New York
- #255 5.8 Da Nico Ristorante New York
- #255 5.8 Luna Ristorante New York
- #255 5.8 Mediterraneo Restaurant New York
- #259 5.7 Angelo Bellini New York
- #259 5.7 Famous Amadeus Pizza New York
- #261 5.6 Stella 34 Trattoria New York
- #262 5.4 42nd Street Pizza New York
- #262 5.4 Ben's Pizzeria New York
- #262 5.4 Flavors of Italy Bistro New York
- #262 5.4 LA Traviata Pizzeria New York
- #262 5.4 Soho 99 Cents Cheese Pizza New York
- #267 5.2 D Napoli Pizza Neapolitan
- #267 5.2 Mangia - Flatiron New York
- #267 5.2 Olio e Piú New York
- #270 5.1 Naples 45 Ristorante E Pizzeria Neapolitan
- #270 5.1 Rosario's Pizza New York
- #270 5.1 Uncle Paul's Pizza New York
- #273 5.0 Patzeria Perfect Pizza New York
- #274 4.9 $1 Pizza New York
- #274 4.9 99 Cent Fresh Pizza New York
- #274 4.9 Gaslight Pizzeria New York
- #274 4.9 Mama Mia 44 SW New York
- #274 4.9 Previti Pizza New York
- #274 4.9 Time Square Dollar Pizza Sicilian/Grandma
- #280 4.8 Adrienne's Pizzabar New York
- #280 4.8 Friendly Gourmet Pizza New York
- #280 4.8 La Rossa New York
- #280 4.8 Pasta Lovers New York
- #280 4.8 Pazza Notte New York
- #280 4.8 Salt & Pepper New York
- #280 4.8 Trenta Tre Pizzeria New York
- #280 4.8 W4 Pizza New York
- #280 4.8 Yankee Pizza New York
- #289 4.6 Don Giovanni Ristorante New York
- #290 4.3 My Pie Pizzeria Romana Roman
- #291 4.2 Big Nick's Burger & Pizza Joint Too New York
- #291 4.2 Little Italy Pizza New York
- #291 4.2 Picasso Pizza New York
- #291 4.2 Pizza Italia New York
- #291 4.2 Pomodoro Pizza New York
- #291 4.2 Pomodoro Ristorante & Pizzeria New York
- #297 4.1 A Slice of New York New York
- #297 4.1 Carve New York
- #299 4.0 Pizza Park New York
- #300 3.9 Libretto's Pizzeria New York
- #301 3.7 Mariella Pizza New York
- #302 3.6 Daniela Trattoria New York
- #303 3.4 5 Boroughs Pizza New York
- #303 3.4 Justino's Pizzeria New York
- #305 3.3 The Grotto Pizzeria & Ristorante New York
- #306 3.2 La Gusto Pizza New York
- #306 3.2 Sbarro New York
- #306 3.2 Stromboli Pizza New York
- #309 3.1 Z Deli Pizzeria New York
- #310 2.9 Hank's Pizza New York
- #311 2.8 Cheska's New York
- #311 2.8 Rocky's Number II New York
- #313 2.7 Intrepid Summer Movie Series New York
- #314 2.5 Da Vinci Pizza New York
- #315 2.4 Stanton Pizza New York
- #316 2.2 Square Pizza & Chicken Sicilian/Grandma
- #316 2.2 Steve's Pizza New York
- #318 2.1 IPizzaNY New York
- #319 1.9 Hell's Kitchen Pizza New York
- #319 1.9 Jekyll & Hyde New York
- #321 1.8 Cafe Viva New York
- #322 1.7 Canal Pizza New York
- #322 1.7 Highline Pizza New York
- #324 1.4 Rocky's Pizza 14th St New York
- #325 1.2 Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant New York
- #325 1.2 Milk Bar East Village New York
- #325 1.2 Rubby's Pizzeria New York
- #328 0.9 Pizza Gaga New York
- #329 0.2 F & M Slice Pizza New York
- #330 0.1 Open Market New York
- #331 0.08 Amtrak New York
- #332 0.02 7-Eleven New York
- #333 0.01 BD Best Pizza New York
- #334 0.0 Café Muse New York
- #334 0.0 Industry Kitchen New York
- TBD Amore Pizza Café New York
- TBD Andiamo Pizza New York
- TBD Chrissy's Pizza New York
- TBD Crispiano New York
- TBD Crispy Heaven New York
- TBD Fiorentina Pizzeria and Grill New York
- TBD Five Boys New York
- TBD Funzi's Pizzeria New York
- TBD Grand Street Pizza New York
- TBD Italian Trattoria New York
- TBD Ledo Pizza New York
- TBD Little Charli New York
- TBD LTD Pizza & Bar New York
- TBD Luv Pizza New York
- TBD Napoli Pizza Neapolitan
- TBD PDA Slice Shop New York
- TBD Pizza and Shakes New York
- TBD Pizza Loves Sauce New York
- TBD Redemption - NYC Pizza Kitchen New York
- TBD Spunto New York
- TBD Traditas Pizza New York
- TBD Uncle Sam's Pizza New York
- TBD Xeno's Pizza New York
- TBD Zillion's Pizzeria New York
Other New York-Style pizza in New York
Top-rated pizza in New York
- Di Fara PizzaBrooklyn · 9.4
- Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaNew York · 9.3
- John's of Bleecker StreetNew York · 9.3
- Lazzara's PizzaNew York · 9.3
- LucaliBrooklyn · 9.3
- Luigi's PizzaBrooklyn · 9.3
- CeresNew York · 9.2
- Best PizzaBrooklyn · 9.1
Every One Bite review in New York →
Scores are Dave Portnoy's, as published by Barstool Sports and compiled from public sources. Restaurants change; check hours and current reviews before you go. One Bite Pizza Reviews is an unofficial fan site. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy or the One Bite app. Scores are reported from public sources; names and trademarks belong to their owners.