Ohio · 46 reviews

Best pizza in Ohio, according to Dave Portnoy

Every Barstool Sports One Bite pizza review in Ohio, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. Average score: 6.23 across 18 scored pizzerias in 12 cities.

Ohio pizza by city

Pizza styles in Ohio

Tap a style to filter the list. What each style means.

All One Bite reviews in Ohio

  1. #1 8.1 Emelio's RestaurantColumbus, OH New York
  2. #2 7.8 Leone's PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  3. #3 7.7 Il RioneCleveland, OH New York
  4. #4 7.6 Vincenza's Pizza & PastaCleveland, OH New York
  5. #5 7.4 Bazemore Pizza CompanyUpper Arlington, OH New York
  6. #5 7.4 GoreMade PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  7. #7 7.2 Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza - AustintownYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley
  8. #8 7.1 Avalon Downtown PizzeriaYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley
  9. #9 7.0 Brier Hill Pizza & WingsYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley
  10. #10 6.9 Sicilia Fine Italian SpecialtiesColumbus, OH New York
  11. #11 6.8 Belleria PizzeriaYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley
  12. #12 6.7 CrustCleveland, OH New York
  13. #13 6.4 Bruno Bros PizzaAustintown, OH New York
  14. #13 6.4 The O Patio & PubColumbus, OH New York
  15. #15 5.4 Adriatico's New York Style PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  16. #16 5.1 Edison's Pizza KitchenCleveland, OH New York
  17. #17 1.2 Catfish Biff's Pizza & SubsColumbus, OH New York
  18. #18 0.0 Dante's InfernoCleveland, OH New York
  19. TBD Adriatico'sCincinnati, OH New York
  20. TBD Angelo's PizzaLakewood, OH New York
  21. TBD Aracri PizzeriaColumbus, OH New York
  22. TBD Artisan Pizza CafeColumbus, OH New York
  23. TBD Bobby Jo's PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  24. TBD Brier Hill PizzaYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley
  25. TBD East Coast PizzeriaColumbus, OH New York
  26. TBD Grandad's Pizza & PubColumbus, OH New York
  27. TBD GuardiaCincinnati, OH New York
  28. TBD Harvest PizzeriaDublin, OH New York
  29. TBD Hounddog's PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  30. TBD Iacono's Pizza & RestaurantPowell, OH New York
  31. TBD JT's Pizza & PubGrandview Heights, OH New York
  32. TBD Leone's Pizza Surprise Pizza AttackColumbus, OH New York
  33. TBD Mamma Santa'sCleveland, OH New York
  34. TBD Marble RoomCleveland, OH New York
  35. TBD Marion's PiazzaDayton, OH New York
  36. TBD Mikey's Late Night SliceColumbus, OH New York
  37. TBD OH Pizza and BrewColumbus, OH New York
  38. TBD Old Scratch Pizza & BeerDayton, OH New York
  39. TBD Pizza 216Cleveland, OH New York
  40. TBD Plank's Cafe & PizzeriaColumbus, OH New York
  41. TBD Sexton's PizzaHilliard, OH New York
  42. TBD Sicilia's PizzaColumbus, OH New York
  43. TBD TaglioCincinnati, OH Roman
  44. TBD Tommy's PizzaDublin, OH New York
  45. TBD Trophy PizzaCincinnati, OH New York
  46. TBD Wedgewood PizzaYoungstown, OH Ohio Valley

Ohio One Bite pizza FAQ

What is the highest-rated One Bite pizza in Ohio?

Emelio's Restaurant in Columbus has the top Dave Portnoy score in Ohio at 8.1. Next is Leone's Pizza in Columbus (7.8).

How many pizzerias has Dave Portnoy reviewed in Ohio?

We list 46 One Bite reviews in Ohio across 12 cities, 18 of them with a published score. The average score is 6.23.

Which Ohio city has the most One Bite reviews?

Columbus leads with 18 reviewed pizzerias, followed by Cleveland (8).

What is the lowest One Bite score in Ohio?

Dante's Inferno in Cleveland has the lowest score in Ohio at 0.0.