Wisconsin · 16 reviews
Best pizza in Wisconsin, according to Dave Portnoy
Every Barstool Sports One Bite pizza review in Wisconsin, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. Average score: 6.60 across 6 scored pizzerias in 4 cities.
- 7.4#1 Lucille, Madison
- 7.4#2 Salvatore's Tomato Pies, Madison
- 6.8#3 Pizza Brutta, Madison
Wisconsin pizza by city
Pizza styles in Wisconsin
Tap a style to filter the list. What each style means.
All One Bite reviews in Wisconsin
- #1 7.4 LucilleMadison, WI New York
- #1 7.4 Salvatore's Tomato PiesMadison, WI Tomato pie
- #3 6.8 Pizza BruttaMadison, WI New York
- #4 6.2 Pizza Di RomaMadison, WI Roman
- #5 6.1 Ian's Pizza by the SliceMadison, WI New York
- #6 5.7 Paisan'sMadison, WI New York
- TBD Brick 3 PizzaMilwaukee, WI New York
- TBD Classic SliceMilwaukee, WI New York
- TBD Grampa's PizzeriaMadison, WI New York
- TBD Greenbush BarMadison, WI New York
- TBD Ian's PizzaMilwaukee, WI New York
- TBD Ian's PizzaMadison, WI New York
- TBD Next Door Pub & PizzeriaLake Geneva, WI New York
- TBD OakfireLake Geneva, WI New York
- TBD Wells BrothersRacine, WI New York
- TBD Zaffiro's PizzaMilwaukee, WI New York
Wisconsin One Bite pizza FAQ
What is the highest-rated One Bite pizza in Wisconsin?
Lucille in Madison has the top Dave Portnoy score in Wisconsin at 7.4. Next is Salvatore's Tomato Pies in Madison (7.4).
How many pizzerias has Dave Portnoy reviewed in Wisconsin?
We list 16 One Bite reviews in Wisconsin across 4 cities, 6 of them with a published score. The average score is 6.60.
Which Wisconsin city has the most One Bite reviews?
Madison leads with 9 reviewed pizzerias, followed by Milwaukee (4).
What is the lowest One Bite score in Wisconsin?
Paisan's in Madison has the lowest score in Wisconsin at 5.7.