New Jersey · 222 reviews

Best pizza in New Jersey, according to Dave Portnoy

Every Barstool Sports One Bite pizza review in New Jersey, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. Average score: 7.47 across 139 scored pizzerias in 121 cities.

New Jersey pizza by city

Plus 61 more cities in the list below.

Pizza styles in New Jersey

Tap a style to filter the list. What each style means.

All One Bite reviews in New Jersey

  1. #1 9.4 DeLucia's Brick Oven PizzaRaritan, NJ Wood-fired
  2. #2 9.2 De Lorenzo's Tomato PiesRobbinsville, NJ Tomato pie
  3. #3 8.9 Brooklyn Square PizzaJackson, NJ Sicilian/Grandma
  4. #3 8.9 Calabria Pizzeria & RestaurantLivingston, NJ New York
  5. #3 8.9 Conte's PizzaPrinceton, NJ New York
  6. #3 8.9 Ralph's PizzeriaNutley, NJ New York
  7. #7 8.8 Angeloni's Restaurant & PizzeriaCaldwell, NJ New York
  8. #7 8.8 Federici's Family RestaurantFreehold, NJ New York
  9. #7 8.8 Nancy's Towne HouseRahway, NJ New York
  10. #10 8.7 Columbia Inn RestaurantMontville, NJ New York
  11. #11 8.6 Nunzio's PizzeriaLong Branch, NJ New York
  12. #11 8.6 Papa's Tomato PiesRobbinsville, NJ Tomato pie
  13. #11 8.6 Tenth Street Pasta & PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  14. #14 8.5 Perfect PizzaNorth Bergen, NJ New York
  15. #14 8.5 Rosie's PizzaPoint Pleasant Beach, NJ New York
  16. #16 8.3 Pizzeria 'LucciBelmar, NJ New York
  17. #16 8.3 Santillo's Brick Oven PizzaElizabeth, NJ Wood-fired
  18. #16 8.3 Vic's Italian RestaurantBradley Beach, NJ New York
  19. #19 8.2 Del Ponte's Coal Fired PizzaBradley Beach, NJ Coal oven
  20. #19 8.2 PaciDough's Pizza JointToms River, NJ New York
  21. #19 8.2 Patsy's Tavern & RestaurantPaterson, NJ Tavern
  22. #22 8.1 Basile's PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  23. #22 8.1 Corner SquareBayonne, NJ Sicilian/Grandma
  24. #22 8.1 Lido RestaurantHackensack, NJ New York
  25. #22 8.1 Luigi's Famous PizzaLincroft, NJ New York
  26. #22 8.1 Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's PizzeriaNeptune City, NJ New York
  27. #22 8.1 Razza Pizza ArtigianaleJersey City, NJ Wood-fired
  28. #22 8.1 Renato's Pizza MasterJersey City, NJ New York
  29. #22 8.1 Spinachio PizzaNorth Haledon, NJ New York
  30. #22 8.1 Urban TomatoPalisades Park, NJ New York
  31. #31 8.0 Fort Lee PizzeriaFort Lee, NJ New York
  32. #31 8.0 Fort Lee PizzeriaFort Lee, NJ New York
  33. #33 7.9 Amano PizzaSouth Amboy, NJ New York
  34. #33 7.9 Amore Pizza by Jack CalandraNutley, NJ New York
  35. #33 7.9 Brooklyn PizzaShort Hills, NJ New York
  36. #33 7.9 Brooklyn's Brick Oven PizzeriaHackensack, NJ Wood-fired
  37. #33 7.9 Casano's Pizza ParlorRutherford, NJ New York
  38. #33 7.9 Ferraro's Pizzeria & PubMiddlesex, NJ New York
  39. #33 7.9 Mancini PizzaEast Brunswick, NJ New York
  40. #33 7.9 Maria's Pizza & SubsMilltown, NJ New York
  41. #33 7.9 Natoli's Italian DeliSecaucus, NJ New York
  42. #33 7.9 Roma PizzeriaNorth Bergen, NJ Roman
  43. #33 7.9 The Galley Pizza & EateryAsbury Park, NJ New York
  44. #33 7.9 Tony D's PizzaCaldwell, NJ New York
  45. #33 7.9 Vinnie's MootzLyndhurst, NJ New York
  46. #46 7.8 Brooklyn SquareJackson, NJ Sicilian/Grandma
  47. #46 7.8 Lodi Pizza RestaurantLodi, NJ New York
  48. #46 7.8 Napoli Wood Fired PizzaCliffside Park, NJ Neapolitan
  49. #46 7.8 The New Park TavernEast Rutherford, NJ Tavern
  50. #46 7.8 The Pizza TerminalVerona, NJ New York
  51. #51 7.7 Bella PizzaHasbrouck Heights, NJ New York
  52. #51 7.7 Curioni's PizzaLodi, NJ New York
  53. #51 7.7 EVOLI Pizzeria & BistroHackensack, NJ New York
  54. #51 7.7 Grana Pizza CafeMatawan, NJ New York
  55. #51 7.7 Lucci's PizzaClifton, NJ New York
  56. #51 7.7 Nonna'sFlorham Park, NJ New York
  57. #51 7.7 Tramonto's PizzaOcean Township, NJ New York
  58. #51 7.7 Urban CoalHouseRed Bank, NJ Coal oven
  59. #59 7.6 Chimney Rock InnBound Brook, NJ New York
  60. #59 7.6 John's PizzeriaJersey City, NJ New York
  61. #59 7.6 Johnny PepperoniHoboken, NJ New York
  62. #59 7.6 Josie's PizzeriaLyndhurst, NJ New York
  63. #59 7.6 Michael's PastariaNutley, NJ New York
  64. #59 7.6 Pizza LandNorth Arlington, NJ New York
  65. #59 7.6 Porrino's PizzeriaLittle Ferry, NJ New York
  66. #59 7.6 Reservoir RestaurantSouth Orange, NJ New York
  67. #59 7.6 Reservoir TavernBoonton, NJ Tavern
  68. #59 7.6 Sea Bright PizzeriaSea Bright, NJ New York
  69. #59 7.6 Squan TavernManasquan, NJ Tavern
  70. #59 7.6 Wayne Ale House & PizzaWayne, NJ New York
  71. #71 7.5 Kinchley's TavernRamsey, NJ Tavern
  72. #71 7.5 Manville Pizza & RestaurantManville, NJ New York
  73. #71 7.5 Maruca's Tomato PiesSeaside Heights, NJ Tomato pie
  74. #71 7.5 Mona Lisa PizzaJackson Township, NJ New York
  75. #71 7.5 Pizza Town USAElmwood Park, NJ New York
  76. #71 7.5 Tavolino Pizzeria & TrattoriaWallington, NJ New York
  77. #71 7.5 Trattoria La SorrentinaNorth Bergen, NJ New York
  78. #78 7.4 Arturo's Osteria & PizzeriaMaplewood, NJ Coal oven
  79. #78 7.4 Barcelona's RestaurantGarfield, NJ New York
  80. #78 7.4 Belgiovine's PizzaMontclair, NJ New York
  81. #78 7.4 Ferazzoli's Italian KitchenRutherford, NJ New York
  82. #78 7.4 Napoli's Brick Oven PizzaHoboken, NJ Neapolitan
  83. #78 7.4 Palermo's Cafe & BakeryLittle Ferry, NJ New York
  84. #78 7.4 Romeo'sFreehold, NJ New York
  85. #78 7.4 Romeo's Pizza Italian AmericanFreehold Township, NJ New York
  86. #78 7.4 TaorminaPaterson, NJ New York
  87. #78 7.4 Three Guys From ItalyKenilworth, NJ New York
  88. #88 7.3 Low FidelityJersey City, NJ New York
  89. #88 7.3 Manco & Manco PizzaOcean City, NJ New York
  90. #88 7.3 Nicholas Barrel & RoostRed Bank, NJ New York
  91. #88 7.3 Oakwood Pizza EdisonEdison, NJ New York
  92. #88 7.3 Pizza RIAManchester Township, NJ New York
  93. #88 7.3 Santoni's PizzeriaGarfield, NJ New York
  94. #88 7.3 Strawberry's Pub & PizzaWoodbridge, NJ New York
  95. #88 7.3 The Brick Fire Baked PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  96. #96 7.2 Capri PizzaKenilworth, NJ New York
  97. #96 7.2 Dusal's Italian RestaurantFreehold, NJ New York
  98. #96 7.2 Joe's RotisseriaRoselle Park, NJ New York
  99. #96 7.2 Mario's Classic PizzaHoboken, NJ New York
  100. #96 7.2 Outta Hand PizzaWestfield, NJ New York
  101. #96 7.2 Tommy's Tavern + TapSea Bright, NJ Tavern
  102. #96 7.2 Vesta Wood Fired Pizza & BarEast Rutherford, NJ Wood-fired
  103. #96 7.2 Zoni's Coal Fired PizzaRed Bank, NJ Coal oven
  104. #104 7.1 Brooklyn Boys Pizza and DeliEdison, NJ New York
  105. #104 7.1 Brothers PizzaEast Brunswick, NJ New York
  106. #104 7.1 Café VillaChatham, NJ New York
  107. #104 7.1 PortaJersey City, NJ New York
  108. #104 7.1 Star TavernOrange, NJ Tavern
  109. #104 7.1 Talula'sAsbury Park, NJ New York
  110. #104 7.1 Vinnie's Pizzeria & RestaurantBloomfield, NJ New York
  111. #111 6.9 Aumm AummNorth Bergen, NJ New York
  112. #111 6.9 M & S Pizza IIRockaway Township, NJ New York
  113. #113 6.8 A1 PizzaLyndhurst, NJ New York
  114. #113 6.8 Benny Tudino's PizzeriaHoboken, NJ New York
  115. #113 6.8 Frank's PizzeriaNewark, NJ New York
  116. #113 6.8 Frankie FedsFreehold, NJ New York
  117. #113 6.8 IL Forno Brick Oven PizzaSecaucus, NJ Wood-fired
  118. #113 6.8 Jojo's PizzaLittle Falls Township, NJ New York
  119. #113 6.8 Piazza Di PizzaMoonachie, NJ New York
  120. #113 6.8 Pizza Time RestaurantAvenel, NJ New York
  121. #113 6.8 Tony Boloney'sHoboken, NJ New York
  122. #113 6.8 Tony Novante's Pizza and Wing BossUnion City, NJ New York
  123. #113 6.8 Vinnie's Pizzeria & RistoranteBoonton, NJ New York
  124. #124 6.7 Giovanni's Pizzeria & RestaurantHoboken, NJ New York
  125. #124 6.7 La Pizza of RoselandRoseland, NJ New York
  126. #124 6.7 Medusa Stone Fired KitchenAsbury Park, NJ New York
  127. #124 6.7 Millie's Old World Meatballs & PizzaMorristown, NJ New York
  128. #124 6.7 Trattoria NapoliUnion City, NJ Neapolitan
  129. #129 6.6 Johnny Mac House of SpiritsAsbury Park, NJ New York
  130. #129 6.6 Mama Rosa Pizza and PastaRutherford, NJ New York
  131. #129 6.6 Sciortino's Pizza Pasta & MPerth Amboy, NJ New York
  132. #132 6.5 Pasquale's PizzaBoonton, NJ New York
  133. #133 6.4 Nino's Restaurant & PizzeriaLodi, NJ New York
  134. #134 6.2 Krispy PizzaJersey City, NJ New York
  135. #135 4.9 Tony's Baltimore GrillAtlantic City, NJ New York
  136. #136 4.8 Three Brothers From ItalySeaside Heights, NJ New York
  137. #137 4.2 Meadowlands Racing and EntertainmentEast Rutherford, NJ New York
  138. #138 3.8 Pizza HutNorth Bergen, NJ New York
  139. #139 1.9 CostcoClifton, NJ New York
  140. TBD Ava's Kitchen & BarKenilworth, NJ New York
  141. TBD BazzarelliMoonachie, NJ New York
  142. TBD Benny's PizzaWoodbridge, NJ New York
  143. TBD Berardi Brothers PizzaSea Isle City, NJ New York
  144. TBD Blue Steel Pizza CompanyBloomfield, NJ New York
  145. TBD Bonvini's PizzaLivingston, NJ New York
  146. TBD Bread & SaltJersey City, NJ New York
  147. TBD Bricco Coal Fired PizzaHaddon Township, NJ Coal oven
  148. TBD Brooklyn Original PizzeriaHaddon Heights, NJ New York
  149. TBD Bruno'sClifton, NJ New York
  150. TBD Bunny's Sports BarSouth Orange, NJ New York

New Jersey One Bite pizza FAQ

What is the highest-rated One Bite pizza in New Jersey?

DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza in Raritan has the top Dave Portnoy score in New Jersey at 9.4. Next is De Lorenzo's Tomato Pies in Robbinsville (9.2).

How many pizzerias has Dave Portnoy reviewed in New Jersey?

We list 222 One Bite reviews in New Jersey across 121 cities, 139 of them with a published score. The average score is 7.47.

Which New Jersey city has the most One Bite reviews?

Hoboken leads with 19 reviewed pizzerias, followed by Jersey City (8).

What is the lowest One Bite score in New Jersey?

Costco in Clifton has the lowest score in New Jersey at 1.9.