New York · 636 reviews

Best pizza in New York, according to Dave Portnoy

Every Barstool Sports One Bite pizza review in New York, ranked by Dave Portnoy's score. Average score: 6.70 across 483 scored pizzerias in 91 cities.

New York pizza by city

Plus 31 more cities in the list below.

Pizza styles in New York

Tap a style to filter the list. What each style means.

All One Bite reviews in New York

  1. #1 9.4 Di Fara PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  2. #2 9.3 Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  3. #2 9.3 John's of Bleecker StreetNew York, NY Coal oven
  4. #2 9.3 Lazzara's PizzaNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  5. #2 9.3 LucaliBrooklyn, NY New York
  6. #2 9.3 Luigi's PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  7. #7 9.2 CeresNew York, NY New York
  8. #8 9.1 Best PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  9. #8 9.1 Johnny's PizzeriaMount Vernon, NY New York
  10. #8 9.1 Sauce PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  11. #11 9.0 Denino's Greenwich VillageNew York, NY New York
  12. #12 8.7 F & F PizzeriaBrooklyn, NY New York
  13. #12 8.7 Ignazio'sBrooklyn, NY New York
  14. #12 8.7 Sorrento'sLong Beach, NY New York
  15. #15 8.6 Joe & Pat's PizzeriaStaten Island, NY New York
  16. #15 8.6 Nove Italian RestaurantGansevoort, NY New York
  17. #15 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  18. #15 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  19. #15 8.6 Prince Street PizzaNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  20. #15 8.6 Rizzo's Fine PizzaNew York, NY New York
  21. #15 8.6 Tommy's PizzaBronx, NY New York
  22. #15 8.6 Umberto's Pizzeria & RestaurantNew Hyde Park, NY New York
  23. #15 8.6 Williamsburg PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  24. #24 8.5 Brooklyn Pizza MastersNew York, NY New York
  25. #24 8.5 Double ZeroNew York, NY New York
  26. #24 8.5 Joe's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  27. #24 8.5 Lil' Frankie'sNew York, NY New York
  28. #28 8.4 Best Pizza & Dive BarAmagansett, NY New York
  29. #28 8.4 Joe & Pat's PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  30. #28 8.4 John's of Times SquareNew York, NY Sicilian/Grandma
  31. #28 8.4 Luigi's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  32. #28 8.4 Nick's PizzaForest Hills, NY Coal oven
  33. #28 8.4 Picciotto NYCNew York, NY New York
  34. #28 8.4 Pizza SamJackson Heights, NY New York
  35. #28 8.4 Saba's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  36. #28 8.4 Trattoria L'incontroAstoria, NY New York
  37. #28 8.4 Vinny VincenzNew York, NY New York
  38. #38 8.3 GatoNew York, NY New York
  39. #38 8.3 SauceNew York, NY New York
  40. #38 8.3 Speedy RomeoNew York, NY New York
  41. #41 8.2 Brick Oven Pizza 33New York, NY Wood-fired
  42. #41 8.2 Brunetti PizzaNew York, NY New York
  43. #41 8.2 Cello's PizzeriaManhattan, NY New York
  44. #41 8.2 Merilu Pizza Al MetroNew York, NY New York
  45. #41 8.2 Numero 28 Pizzeria - West VillageNew York, NY New York
  46. #41 8.2 NY Pizza SupremaNew York, NY New York
  47. #41 8.2 Pizza TimeBrooklyn, NY New York
  48. #41 8.2 Pope's Italian RestaurantSaratoga Springs, NY New York
  49. #41 8.2 Rocco's Pizza JointNew York, NY New York
  50. #41 8.2 Saluggi'sNew York, NY New York
  51. #41 8.2 Stromboli PizzaNew York, NY New York
  52. #41 8.2 The LongshoremanNew York, NY New York
  53. #53 8.1 310 Bowery BarNew York, NY New York
  54. #53 8.1 Amore PizzeriaFlushing, NY New York
  55. #53 8.1 Cafe Daniello'sNew York, NY New York
  56. #53 8.1 Caputo's PizzeriaSaratoga Springs, NY New York
  57. #53 8.1 Champion PizzaNew York, NY New York
  58. #53 8.1 Denino's Pizzeria TavernStaten Island, NY Tavern
  59. #53 8.1 Famous Ben's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  60. #53 8.1 Francesco's PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  61. #53 8.1 Freddie & Pepper'sNew York, NY New York
  62. #53 8.1 Jiannetto's Pizza TruckNew York, NY New York
  63. #53 8.1 King Umberto's of ElmontElmont, NY New York
  64. #53 8.1 L'Arte Della Pizza BrooklynBrooklyn, NY New York
  65. #53 8.1 Lo Duca PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  66. #53 8.1 Lombardi's pizzaNew York, NY Coal oven
  67. #53 8.1 Luigi's Gourmet GrillNew York, NY New York
  68. #53 8.1 Neapolitan ExpressNew York, NY Neapolitan
  69. #53 8.1 Nicoletta PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  70. #53 8.1 Pisa PizzaNew York, NY New York
  71. #53 8.1 PizzArteNew York, NY New York
  72. #53 8.1 Pizzeria GioveStaten Island, NY New York
  73. #53 8.1 RubirosaNew York, NY New York
  74. #53 8.1 Sacco PizzaNew York, NY New York
  75. #53 8.1 Sal's Little ItalyNew York, NY New York
  76. #53 8.1 SliceLong Island City, NY New York
  77. #53 8.1 Sullivan Street Bakery and PizzaManhattan, NY Roman
  78. #53 8.1 Totonno'sBrooklyn, NY Coal oven
  79. #79 8.0 East Village PizzaNew York, NY New York
  80. #79 8.0 Grimaldi'sBrooklyn, NY Coal oven
  81. #79 8.0 La Margarita PizzaNew York, NY New York
  82. #79 8.0 Roberta'sBrooklyn, NY Wood-fired
  83. #83 7.9 Artichoke Basille's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  84. #83 7.9 Arturo'sNew York, NY Coal oven
  85. #83 7.9 Borrelli'sEast Meadow, NY New York
  86. #83 7.9 Brother's PizzeriaStaten Island, NY New York
  87. #83 7.9 Fresco By ScottoNew York, NY New York
  88. #83 7.9 Gino's Long BeachLong Beach, NY New York
  89. #83 7.9 Grand Avenue PizzaAstoria, NY New York
  90. #83 7.9 Il Mattone West VillageNew York, NY New York
  91. #83 7.9 L'industrie PizzeriaBrooklyn, NY New York
  92. #83 7.9 Lee's TavernStaten Island, NY Tavern
  93. #83 7.9 Made In New York PizzaNew York, NY New York
  94. #83 7.9 Manhattan Brick Oven PizzaNew York, NY Wood-fired
  95. #83 7.9 Moby'sEast Hampton, NY New York
  96. #83 7.9 Nunzio's Pizzeria & RestaurantStaten Island, NY New York
  97. #83 7.9 Patrizia's Pizza and PastaNew York, NY New York
  98. #83 7.9 Pizzeria La RosaNew Rochelle, NY New York
  99. #83 7.9 Rock Pizza ScissorsNew York, NY New York
  100. #83 7.9 Sofia Pizza ShoppeNew York, NY New York
  101. #83 7.9 Tony's PizzaBrooklyn, NY New York
  102. #83 7.9 Via Roma Pizza BarBrooklyn, NY Roman
  103. #103 7.8 Adoro LeiNew York, NY New York
  104. #103 7.8 Artichoke Basille's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  105. #103 7.8 Botanica BarNew York, NY New York
  106. #103 7.8 Carmine's PizzeriaBrooklyn, NY New York
  107. #103 7.8 Eddie's PizzaNew Hyde Park, NY New York
  108. #103 7.8 Emmett'sNew York, NY New York
  109. #103 7.8 Frank's TrattoriaNew York, NY New York
  110. #103 7.8 Joe's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  111. #103 7.8 Krispy Pizza - BrooklynBrooklyn, NY New York
  112. #103 7.8 La BellezzaNew York, NY New York
  113. #103 7.8 Louie & Ernie's PizzaBronx, NY New York
  114. #103 7.8 Marabella PizzaSunnyside, NY New York
  115. #103 7.8 New Park PizzaHoward Beach, NY New York
  116. #103 7.8 Nonna's PizzaWhite Plains, NY New York
  117. #103 7.8 Pelham PizzaPelham, NY New York
  118. #103 7.8 PeperinoNew York, NY New York
  119. #103 7.8 Pizza Da SoloNew York, NY New York
  120. #103 7.8 Rivoli PizzaNew York, NY New York
  121. #103 7.8 Round Pie Pizza CompanyStaten Island, NY New York
  122. #103 7.8 Salvo's PizzabarNew York, NY New York
  123. #103 7.8 Sam's RestaurantEast Hampton, NY New York
  124. #103 7.8 Serafina MeatpackingNew York, NY New York
  125. #103 7.8 Stretch PizzaManhattan, NY New York
  126. #103 7.8 Vaccaro's PizzaFloral Park, NY New York
  127. #103 7.8 Zazzy's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  128. #128 7.7 3 GiovaniNew York, NY New York
  129. #128 7.7 Ciao Vineria con CucinaNew York, NY New York
  130. #128 7.7 Harry's ItalianNew York, NY New York
  131. #128 7.7 Il Buco Alimentari & VineriaNew York, NY New York
  132. #128 7.7 Italian Village PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  133. #128 7.7 Michael's Famous Pan Pizza & RestaurantPort Chester, NY New York
  134. #128 7.7 Mike's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  135. #128 7.7 Pepe GialloNew York, NY New York
  136. #128 7.7 Phil's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  137. #128 7.7 Pugsley's PizzaBronx, NY New York
  138. #128 7.7 Rosario'sAstoria, NY New York
  139. #128 7.7 Sal's PizzeriaMamaroneck, NY New York
  140. #128 7.7 Scarr's PizzaNew York, NY New York
  141. #128 7.7 Sfila PizzaNew York, NY New York
  142. #128 7.7 Song E NapuleNew York, NY Neapolitan
  143. #128 7.7 Table 87 - Brooklyn HeightsBrooklyn, NY New York
  144. #128 7.7 VezzoNew York, NY New York
  145. #145 7.6 Arthur Avenue Wood Fired PizzaPleasantville, NY Wood-fired
  146. #145 7.6 Enzo Bruni La Pizza GourmetNew York, NY New York
  147. #145 7.6 Frank & Danny's PizzeriaNew York, NY New York
  148. #145 7.6 Gino's RestaurantBrooklyn, NY New York
  149. #145 7.6 La CapanninaWainscott, NY New York
  150. #145 7.6 MotorinoNew York, NY New York

New York One Bite pizza FAQ

What is the highest-rated One Bite pizza in New York?

Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn has the top Dave Portnoy score in New York at 9.4. Next is Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria in New York (9.3).

How many pizzerias has Dave Portnoy reviewed in New York?

We list 636 One Bite reviews in New York across 91 cities, 483 of them with a published score. The average score is 6.70.

Which New York city has the most One Bite reviews?

New York leads with 360 reviewed pizzerias, followed by Brooklyn (70).

What is the lowest One Bite score in New York?

Industry Kitchen in New York has the lowest score in New York at 0.0.