Pizza style · New York City and the Northeast · Early 1900s

Coal-Fired pizza

The original high-heat American pizza: smoky, blistered, crisp-chewy pies from ovens that are nearly impossible to build anymore.

Also called: Coal-oven pizza, Coal-fired brick oven pizza, Anthracite oven pizza.

Coal-fired pizza is less a single regional style than a cooking tradition, and it is the one that gave American pizza its start. The earliest pizzerias in New York and New Haven baked in brick ovens fired with coal, which was cheap, plentiful and capable of producing ferocious heat. The pies that came out were thin, blistered and smoky, with a crisp yet chewy crust that is still the reference point for a certain kind of old-school pizza.

Today coal ovens are a living relic. Environmental rules make new ones difficult to build in many places, so the coal-fired pizzerias that remain carry an aura of history. Some are century-old institutions, others are newer operators who found a way to keep the tradition burning, and a few chains have built their identity around it.

The origin and history of coal-fired pizza

In the early twentieth century, coal was the standard fuel for commercial bakeries in Northeastern cities. Italian immigrant bakers in New York used existing coal-fired bread ovens to bake pizza, and the first generation of pizzerias inherited that technology. Lombardi's in Manhattan, commonly cited as dating to 1905, is famous for its coal oven, though the first-pizzeria claim is disputed.

A cluster of New York pizzerias from that era kept coal at the center of their identity, including Totonno's in Coney Island, which dates to 1924, John's of Bleecker Street from 1929, and Patsy's in East Harlem from 1933. In New Haven, Frank Pepe's opened in 1925 with a coal-fired oven, and coal remains essential to its pies. New Jersey and other parts of the Northeast developed their own coal-oven pizzerias over the decades as well.

Coal-fired pizza dough and how it is prepared

Coal-oven dough is generally a simple bread-style dough of flour, water, salt and yeast. Many coal-oven pizzerias lean toward a lean formula with little or no sugar or oil, because sugar can scorch quickly at very high heat. The dough is usually fermented for at least a day to build flavor and extensibility.

Pies are stretched thin by hand, with a modest rim. Because coal ovens bake so quickly and intensely, the dough must be strong enough to puff and blister without tearing, but thin enough to cook through in a few minutes.

Coal-fired pizza sauce, cheese and toppings

The classic coal-oven pie is minimalist. A thin layer of crushed tomato is topped with mozzarella, often fresh mozzarella laid down in slices or patches rather than shredded edge to edge, plus grated hard cheese, olive oil and sometimes fresh basil. That arrangement creates pockets of sauce and cheese and lets the charred crust show through.

Toppings tend to be traditional: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, anchovies and garlic. Many old coal-oven pizzerias are whole-pie only, with no slices sold, and some keep the menu deliberately short.

The coal oven and cooking technique

A traditional coal oven is a large, deep brick chamber with a coal fire burning in a compartment to one side or the back of the floor. Pizzerias typically burn anthracite coal, a hard coal that burns hot and relatively clean. Coal ovens are commonly reported to run in roughly the 800 to 900 degree range, though temperatures vary across the floor and over the course of a night.

At that heat a pie bakes in roughly 3 to 6 minutes. The pizza maker rotates and moves pies with a long peel to manage hot spots near the fire, aiming for a crust with leopard-like blistering, a crisp bottom and a chewy interior. The coal fire also gives a faint smoky, mineral quality that devotees insist cannot be replicated in gas or electric ovens.

Modern air-quality regulations have made new coal ovens difficult or impossible to permit in many cities, including New York, so many of the remaining ovens are older installations allowed to keep operating. That scarcity is a big part of the mystique.

Lore and legends of coal-fired pizza

The story of Patsy Grimaldi captures coal-oven lore. Grimaldi, whose uncle Patsy Lancieri founded Patsy's in East Harlem, opened a coal-oven pizzeria under the Brooklyn Bridge in 1990. A naming dispute led him to rename it Grimaldi's, which later became a chain, and he later returned to the same block with Juliana's in 2012. The tale is a reminder of how tightly knit and family-driven the coal-oven world is.

Another enduring legend is that coal ovens are banned outright in New York. More precisely, regulations make new ones extremely difficult to install, while existing ovens may continue under rules for older equipment. Grimaldi's and Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza, a Florida-born chain, have built coal ovens in other states, showing the technique can travel even where it is rare.

What makes a great coal-fired pizza, and how to eat it

A coal oven gives pizza makers enormous heat to work with, but that heat is unforgiving. Here is how to tell a great coal-fired pie from a merely burnt one.

  • Blistering: dark, bubbly spots on the rim and bottom, with golden brown between them.
  • Texture: a crisp exterior that gives way to a tender, chewy crumb rather than a cracker or a doughy center.
  • Smoke: a faint smoky, toasty flavor that complements rather than overwhelms the tomato.
  • Cheese: melted and creamy, with patches of fresh mozzarella that have not broken into grease.
  • How to eat it: share whole pies at the table, eat them right away while the crust is crisp, and fold slices if the center is thin.

Where to find coal-fired pizza

New York City, particularly Manhattan, Brooklyn and Coney Island, has the deepest concentration of historic coal ovens. New Haven, Connecticut, is the other great coal-oven city, and northern New Jersey has its own longtime coal-fired pizzerias.

Outside the Northeast, coal ovens are scarce. A few chains and independent operators have built them in Florida, Arizona, Texas and other states, and diners who seek out the style often plan trips around the remaining historic ovens.

Coal-Fired in a One Bite review

Coal-fired pizza tends to hand a one-bite cheese-slice review its most dramatic undercarriage. The format exposes char right away, and coal ovens deliver blistered, sometimes heavily blackened bottoms that can read as masterful or overdone depending on the night. The thin crust usually holds its structure well, while patchy fresh mozzarella and light sauce can make the sauce-cheese balance vary bite to bite. Whole-pie-only spots also mean the slice is usually fresh rather than reheated, which tends to help.

Dave Portnoy's Coal-Fired pizza rankings

Every Coal-Fired pizzeria in the One Bite reviews, ranked by score. Our style labels come from the pizzeria's name, oven and regional tradition, with editor checks on the best-known spots.

  1. #1 9.3 Angelo's Coal Oven PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  2. #1 9.3 John's of Bleecker StreetNew York, NY Coal oven
  3. #3 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  4. #3 8.6 Patsy's PizzeriaNew York, NY Coal oven
  5. #5 8.4 Nick's PizzaForest Hills, NY Coal oven
  6. #6 8.2 Del Ponte's Coal Fired PizzaBradley Beach, NJ Coal oven
  7. #7 8.1 Lombardi's pizzaNew York, NY Coal oven
  8. #7 8.1 Totonno'sBrooklyn, NY Coal oven
  9. #7 8.1 Tucci's Fire N Coal PizzaBoca Raton, FL Coal oven
  10. #10 8.0 Grimaldi'sBrooklyn, NY Coal oven
  11. #11 7.9 Arturo'sNew York, NY Coal oven
  12. #12 7.8 Luigi's Coal Oven PizzaFort Lauderdale, FL Coal oven
  13. #13 7.7 Urban CoalHouseRed Bank, NJ Coal oven
  14. #14 7.6 Salvatore's Coal Oven PizzeriaPort Washington, NY Coal oven
  15. #15 7.4 Arturo's Osteria & PizzeriaMaplewood, NJ Coal oven
  16. #15 7.4 CoalfireChicago, IL Coal oven
  17. #15 7.4 CoalfireChicago, IL Coal oven
  18. #15 7.4 Providence Coal Fired PizzaProvidence, RI Coal oven
  19. #19 7.3 Campania Coal Fired PizzaNew York, NY Coal oven
  20. #20 7.2 Zoni's Coal Fired PizzaRed Bank, NJ Coal oven
  21. #21 7.1 Nick's PizzaDeerfield Beach, FL Coal oven
  22. #22 6.9 Juliana's PizzaBrooklyn, NY Coal oven
  23. #22 6.9 Michael's Ali Coal Fired PizzaWinter Garden, FL Coal oven
  24. #24 6.8 Arigna Irish Pub & Coal Fire KitchenNorth Providence, RI Coal oven
  25. #25 6.6 Nick's PizzaNew York, NY Coal oven
  26. #26 6.2 Lombardi's PizzaNew York, NY Coal oven
  27. #27 5.9 Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & WingsNorth Miami, FL Coal oven
  28. TBD Angela's Coal Fired PizzaSaugus, MA Coal oven
  29. TBD Anthony's Coal Fired PizzaMiami, FL Coal oven
  30. TBD Bricco Coal Fired PizzaHaddon Township, NJ Coal oven
  31. TBD Bucks Coal Fired PizzaNorth Palm Beach, FL Coal oven
  32. TBD Jack's Coal Fired PizzaBurlington, MA Coal oven
  33. TBD Lombardi's Bar & RestaurantCedar Grove, NJ Coal oven
  34. TBD Marcello's Coal Fired PizzaBordentown, NJ Coal oven
  35. TBD Marco's Coal FiredDenver, CO Coal oven
  36. TBD Max's Coal Oven PizzeriaAtlanta, GA Coal oven
  37. TBD Nicky's Coal FiredNashville, TN Coal oven
  38. TBD Sasso's Coal Fired PizzaTorrington, CT Coal oven
  39. TBD Sicily Coal Fired PizzaMiddletown, CT Coal oven
  40. TBD SLYCE Coal Fired Pizza CompanyWauconda, IL Coal oven
  41. TBD The Marsh Coal Fired PizzaMarshfield, MA Coal oven
  42. TBD Ungaro Coal Fired PizzaStaten Island, NY Coal oven

Coal-Fired pizza FAQ

What is the difference between coal-fired and wood-fired pizza?

Both use high-heat brick ovens, but coal ovens burn anthracite coal for steady, intense heat, while wood-fired ovens burn hardwood with a visible flame. Coal-oven pies are typically American-style and bake in a few minutes, while many wood-fired pies follow Neapolitan traditions.

Are coal ovens illegal in New York City?

They are not banned outright, but air-quality regulations make new coal ovens very difficult to permit. Many existing coal ovens continue under rules for older equipment.

How hot does a coal pizza oven get?

Coal ovens are commonly reported to run around 800 to 900 degrees Fahrenheit. Temperatures vary across the oven floor and throughout service.

What kind of coal is used in pizza ovens?

Most coal-fired pizzerias use anthracite, a hard coal that burns hot and relatively cleanly. It has long been mined in Pennsylvania.

More pizza styles