Pizza style · Steubenville, Ohio, and the Upper Ohio Valley · 1940s

Ohio Valley-Style pizza

A hot square of baked crust and sauce topped with cold cheese and pepperoni: the Upper Ohio Valley's most argued-about pizza.

Also called: Ohio Valley pizza, Steubenville-style pizza, DiCarlo's-style pizza, Cold cheese pizza.

Ohio Valley-style pizza breaks one of pizza's basic rules. The crust and sauce are baked together in a rectangular pan, and then, after the pie comes out of the oven, cold shredded cheese and toppings like pepperoni are piled on top. The heat of the crust melts the cheese only slightly, if at all, depending on how quickly it is eaten or whether the box is closed.

The style is found along the Upper Ohio Valley, where Ohio, West Virginia and Pennsylvania meet, and it is closely associated with DiCarlo's, the family pizzeria credited with creating it. For locals, it is a beloved regional comfort food. For visitors, the cold cheese can be startling.

The origin of Ohio Valley-style pizza

Ohio Valley-style pizza is credited to DiCarlo's in Steubenville, Ohio, which is commonly cited as opening in 1945. The DiCarlo family's bakery background and post-World War II demand for quick, affordable food are often cited as part of how the style developed.

DiCarlo's expanded to other locations in the region, including Wheeling, West Virginia, and the style spread through the Upper Ohio Valley, where it became the default pizza for many families in towns along the river.

Ohio Valley-style pizza dough and how it is prepared

Ohio Valley-style dough is pressed into rectangular sheet pans and baked into a medium-thick, slightly bready crust with a crisp bottom. It is closer to a bakery-style pan pizza than to a thin, hand-stretched pie.

The dough is typically par-baked or baked fully with the sauce, which creates a sturdy base that can hold cold toppings without going soggy.

Ohio Valley-style pizza sauce, cheese and toppings

The sauce is spread on the dough and baked with it, so it reduces and caramelizes slightly. The cheese, typically shredded provolone, is added cold after baking, along with toppings such as pepperoni.

Because the cheese and toppings are added cold, they keep their raw texture, and the cheese melts only slightly from the heat of the crust. Many customers close the box for a few minutes so the steam softens the cheese a little.

The oven and cooking technique behind Ohio Valley-style pizza

Ohio Valley-style pizza bakes in gas deck ovens in rectangular sheet pans, typically around 450 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, for roughly 10 to 15 minutes, until the crust is golden and the sauce has set.

After baking, the pie is cut into squares and topped with cold cheese and toppings. Pizzerias typically sell it by the square or by the tray, and trays are a common order for family gatherings and parties.

Lore and legends of Ohio Valley-style pizza

The cold cheese is the center of Ohio Valley pizza lore. Locals debate how best to eat it: right away with cold cheese, after closing the box so the cheese softens, or reheated at home. Arguments over the proper way are part of the culture.

There are also stories about how the cold cheese tradition started, with some suggesting it was a practical way to sell pizza quickly or to make it travel well. Those explanations are plausible but are best treated as local lore rather than documented history.

What makes a great Ohio Valley-style pizza, and how to eat it

Ohio Valley-style pizza is about the contrast between a warm, crisp crust and cool, fresh toppings. Here is what to look for.

  • Crust: golden and crisp on the bottom, slightly bready inside, never soggy.
  • Sauce: well-seasoned and baked onto the crust, adding sweetness and depth.
  • Cheese: fresh, flavorful provolone that melts slightly from the heat of the crust.
  • Toppings: generous pepperoni added after baking.
  • Temperature: a hot crust is key, so the cheese starts to soften.
  • How to eat it: eat it right away to experience the contrast, or close the box for a few minutes if you want the cheese softer.

Where to find Ohio Valley-style pizza

The Upper Ohio Valley, including Steubenville, Ohio, and Wheeling and Weirton, West Virginia, is the heartland. DiCarlo's and other regional pizzerias serve the style in towns along the river.

Outside the region, Ohio Valley-style pizza is rare, though transplants and a few pizzerias in Pittsburgh, Columbus and elsewhere offer it.

Ohio Valley-Style in a One Bite review

Ohio Valley-style pizza presents perhaps the strangest test for a one-bite cheese-slice format, because the cheese is not baked at all. The undercarriage and structure of the crust can be strengths, with a crisp, sturdy square that holds its shape. But the cold, barely melted provolone is the defining feature, and whether it reads as a regional delight or a puzzling departure from pizza depends on the palate. Sauce and cheese balance takes on a very different meaning when one is baked and the other is not.

Dave Portnoy's Ohio Valley-Style pizza rankings

Every Ohio Valley-Style pizzeria in the One Bite reviews, ranked by score. Our style labels come from the pizzeria's name, oven and regional tradition, with editor checks on the best-known spots.

Ohio Valley-Style pizza FAQ

Why is the cheese cold on Ohio Valley pizza?

The cheese and toppings are added after the crust and sauce are baked. The heat of the crust melts the cheese only slightly, which is the signature of the style.

Who invented Ohio Valley-style pizza?

It is credited to DiCarlo's in Steubenville, Ohio, commonly cited as opening in 1945. The family pizzeria later expanded to other locations in the region.

What cheese is used on Ohio Valley pizza?

Ohio Valley-style pizza is typically topped with shredded provolone added cold after baking.

Can you heat up Ohio Valley pizza?

Yes, many people close the box to soften the cheese or reheat squares at home. Purists often prefer it fresh, with the contrast between hot crust and cool cheese.

More pizza styles