Square pies occupy a special place in American pizza culture. The Sicilian slice, thick and airy with a crisp, oil-fried bottom, has been a fixture of New York pizzerias for generations. Its younger sibling, the grandma pie, is thinner, denser and more rustic, with crushed tomato dotted over the cheese and a hit of garlic and olive oil.
Both trace their spirit to the home-style pan pizzas of southern Italy, particularly the sfincione of Palermo. In the United States, they evolved into something distinct, and at many pizzerias the square slice is the item regulars order when they want the best thing on the counter.
The origin of Sicilian and grandma pizza
In Palermo, sfincione is a thick, spongy pan pizza topped with tomato sauce, onions, anchovies, breadcrumbs, oregano and a local cheese such as caciocavallo. It is sold in bakeries and from street carts, and it is very different from the Neapolitan round pie. Sicilian immigrants brought this tradition of thick, pan-baked pizza to the United States.
In New York, the Sicilian slice evolved into a thick, square pie with an airy crumb, topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce. L&B Spumoni Gardens in Gravesend, Brooklyn, which dates to 1939, is famous for its square, with the cheese laid down first and sauce spread on top. The grandma pie emerged later from home baking on Long Island, where Italian-American families made thinner pan pizzas without a long proof. Umberto's in New Hyde Park is commonly credited with helping bring the grandma slice into pizzerias, and its popularity spread widely from the 1990s onward.
Sicilian and grandma pizza dough and how it is prepared
Sicilian dough is pressed into a generously oiled rectangular pan and allowed to proof, often for hours, until it rises into a thick, bubbly layer. That proof creates an open, focaccia-like crumb, while the oil in the pan fries the bottom into a crisp, golden crust. Some pizzerias par-bake the base before topping it.
Grandma dough is stretched into the pan and topped with little or no extra rise, which results in a thinner, denser crust that is crisp at the edges and chewy in the center. Many recipes use the same dough as a pizzeria's round pies, so the difference comes down mostly to pan, oil and proof time.
Sicilian and grandma pizza sauce, cheese and toppings
Sicilian squares typically get a thick tomato sauce and mozzarella, and in the Brooklyn tradition associated with L&B, the sauce goes on top of the cheese, sometimes finished with grated hard cheese. That arrangement keeps the sauce from soaking into the dough and lets it caramelize slightly in the oven.
Grandma pies usually start with mozzarella spread over the dough, then dollops or stripes of crushed tomato, followed by garlic, olive oil, grated cheese and basil. Pepperoni squares, particularly those topped with small cupping pepperoni that crisps into little cups, have become one of the most sought-after slices in New York.
The oven and cooking technique for Sicilian and grandma pizza
Most square pies bake in standard gas deck ovens, in dark steel or aluminum sheet pans coated with olive oil or a mix of oils. Ovens commonly run somewhere around 450 to 550 degrees Fahrenheit, and a thick Sicilian pie can take roughly 15 to 25 minutes, while a grandma pie often bakes faster.
Many pizzerias pull the pie from the pan near the end of the bake and finish it directly on the oven floor to crisp the bottom further. The oil in the pan is essential, effectively frying the base and giving it the crunchy, golden underside that defines a good square.
Lore and legends of Sicilian and grandma pizza
L&B Spumoni Gardens is the patron saint of the Brooklyn square, and its outdoor tables have hosted generations of families eating squares and spumoni. On Long Island, the origin of the grandma pie inspires friendly disputes among pizzerias, and most accounts credit home cooks rather than a single inventor.
In Manhattan, Prince Street Pizza, which opened in 2012, helped turn the pepperoni square into a social media sensation. The broader lore of the square is that regulars treat it as the insider's order, and the corner pieces, with crisp edges on two sides, are the most coveted.
What makes a great Sicilian or grandma slice, and how to eat it
A great square is all about the contrast between a crisp, fried bottom and a tender interior. Here is what to look for.
- Bottom: golden and crisp from the oiled pan, not pale, soggy or burnt.
- Crumb: airy and light in a Sicilian, never dense or gummy; chewy and compact in a grandma.
- Sauce: bright and flavorful enough to stand up to the thick crust.
- Edges: well-browned, especially on corner pieces.
- Grease: an oily bottom is expected, but the slice should not be dripping.
- How to eat it: eat it by hand, starting from the corner if you are lucky enough to get one. Squares are sturdy and rarely need folding.
Where to find Sicilian and grandma pizza
New York City and Long Island are the heartland, and nearly every pizzeria in the region offers a square or grandma slice. New Jersey, Connecticut and the Philadelphia area also have strong square-pie traditions.
Nationally, square pies have ridden the wave of interest in pan pizza, and many newer pizzerias across the country offer grandma pies alongside their round pies. Palermo and Sicily remain the place to try sfincione in its original form.
Sicilian & Grandma in a One Bite review
Square slices tend to give a one-bite review a different set of things to examine. Structure is rarely a problem since the crust is thick and sturdy, so the focus shifts to the undercarriage, which should be crisp and fried rather than soft, and to the crumb, which can be light or disappointingly doughy. When the sauce is on top, the sauce-cheese balance is front and center, and the oil from the pan makes grease a constant factor to judge.