Pizza style · Chicago and the Midwest · 1930s to 1940s

Tavern-Style Thin Crust pizza

Cracker-thin, cut into squares and made for sharing over a beer: the pizza Chicagoans actually eat most nights.

Also called: Chicago thin crust, Party cut pizza, Tavern cut pizza, Square-cut thin crust, Midwest thin crust.

Tavern-style pizza is the Midwest's everyday pizza: a round pie with a cracker-thin, crispy crust, a layer of seasoned tomato sauce and mozzarella running nearly to the edge, and toppings scattered across the surface. The defining touch is the cut. Instead of wedges, the pie is cut into a grid of small squares, a style known as the party cut or tavern cut.

Despite the global fame of deep dish, many Chicagoans will tell you that tavern-style thin crust is the city's true local pizza. It is the pizza of neighborhood bars, family dinners, birthday parties and Friday nights, and in recent years it has gained a national following.

The origin of tavern-style pizza

Tavern-style pizza is generally traced to Chicago's neighborhood taverns in the years after Prohibition ended in 1933. Bar owners began offering thin, inexpensive pizza cut into small pieces that could be shared and eaten as bar snacks, encouraging patrons to stay and keep drinking.

Several long-running Chicago institutions are associated with the style's early days. Home Run Inn, which began as a tavern in the 1920s, is commonly cited as starting to serve pizza in the 1940s, and many other neighborhood bars and pizzerias developed their own takes over the following decades.

Tavern-style pizza dough and how it is prepared

Tavern dough is a relatively stiff, low-hydration dough, often containing a bit of oil. It is rolled out very thin, frequently with a rolling pin or a sheeter, rather than hand-stretched. That produces a uniform, cracker-like crust instead of an airy, chewy one.

Some pizzerias let the rolled dough rest or dry slightly, sometimes uncovered in a cooler, which helps the crust crisp and gives it a distinctive snap. Cornmeal is often used on the peel or the bottom of the crust, adding crunch and a slightly gritty texture.

Tavern-style pizza sauce, cheese and toppings

Tavern sauce is typically seasoned with oregano, garlic and sometimes a touch of sugar, and it is spread nearly to the edge, leaving almost no outer crust. Mozzarella covers the whole surface.

The classic topping is Italian sausage flavored with fennel, often pinched into small raw pieces and scattered across the pie so it cooks in the oven. Giardiniera, a spicy pickled vegetable relish, is another Chicago favorite, along with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and green peppers.

The oven and cooking technique behind tavern-style pizza

Most tavern-style pizza bakes in gas deck ovens, directly on the stone or on screens or pans. Ovens commonly run around 450 to 550 degrees Fahrenheit, and pies typically bake for roughly 10 to 15 minutes.

The goal is a crust that is crisp throughout and lightly browned on the bottom, with cheese that is melted and blistered in spots. Some pizzerias bake the pie until the edges are almost dark, prizing the crunchy edge pieces.

Lore and legends of tavern-style pizza

The party cut is the heart of tavern lore. The small squares made the pizza easy to share among a crowd at the bar, and they created two kinds of pieces: the crispy, irregular edge pieces and the soft, cheesy center squares. Debate over which is better is a time-honored Midwestern argument.

Another piece of lore is the long-running rivalry between thin crust and deep dish within Chicago itself. Many locals insist that tavern-style is what Chicagoans really eat, and that deep dish is mostly for tourists and special occasions.

What makes a great tavern-style pizza, and how to eat it

Tavern pizza is about crunch and shareability. These are the marks of a good one.

  • Crust: thin, crisp and cracker-like all the way through, with a snap when you bite it.
  • Coverage: sauce, cheese and toppings that reach almost to the edge.
  • Sausage: well-seasoned with fennel and browned, not pale or greasy.
  • Edges: crunchy and well-browned, with the corner pieces worth fighting over.
  • Grease: a little shine is normal, but the crust should stay crisp.
  • How to eat it: grab squares by hand straight from the tray, and choose your camp, edge pieces or center pieces.

Where to find tavern-style pizza

Chicago and its suburbs remain the heartland, with neighborhood pizzerias and bars serving tavern-style pies in nearly every part of the city.

Variants appear across the Midwest, from Milwaukee and Minneapolis to Iowa, Nebraska and Kansas, and the party cut is common throughout the region. In recent years, tavern-style has gained attention nationally, with pizzerias on both coasts adopting the style.

Tavern-Style Thin Crust in a One Bite review

Tavern-style pizza presents a one-bite format with an unusual challenge, because the party cut means there is no classic wedge slice to hold up. What the style can show off is a crisp, cracker-like undercarriage that snaps rather than droops, and structure is usually its strength. The tests become whether the crust is crunchy rather than tough or burnt, whether the sauce and cheese are balanced across such a thin base, and whether grease is softening the crust.

Dave Portnoy's Tavern-Style Thin Crust pizza rankings

Every Tavern-Style Thin Crust pizzeria in the One Bite reviews, ranked by score. Our style labels come from the pizzeria's name, oven and regional tradition, with editor checks on the best-known spots.

  1. #1 8.2 Patsy's Tavern & RestaurantPaterson, NJ Tavern
  2. #2 8.1 Denino's Pizzeria TavernStaten Island, NY Tavern
  3. #2 8.1 PIZZ' AMICIChicago, IL Tavern
  4. #2 8.1 Vito & Nick's PizzeriaChicago, IL Tavern
  5. #5 7.9 Lee's TavernStaten Island, NY Tavern
  6. #5 7.9 Zarella Pizzeria & TavernaChicago, IL Tavern
  7. #7 7.8 Pat's Pizza and RistoranteChicago, IL Tavern
  8. #7 7.8 The New Park TavernEast Rutherford, NJ Tavern
  9. #9 7.7 Craft PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  10. #10 7.6 Bar CargoChicago, IL Tavern
  11. #10 7.6 Jimmy's Pizza CafeChicago, IL Tavern
  12. #10 7.6 Michael's Original Pizzeria & TavernChicago, IL Tavern
  13. #10 7.6 Reservoir TavernBoonton, NJ Tavern
  14. #10 7.6 Squan TavernManasquan, NJ Tavern
  15. #15 7.5 DeNucci'sChicago, IL Tavern
  16. #15 7.5 Kinchley's TavernRamsey, NJ Tavern
  17. #17 7.4 Freddy's PizzaCicero, IL Tavern
  18. #17 7.4 Massa Cafe ItalianoElmwood Park, IL Tavern
  19. #17 7.4 Parlor Pizza Bar West LoopChicago, IL Tavern
  20. #17 7.4 Sharpies Pizza + CocktailsChicago, IL Tavern
  21. #21 7.3 Pizzeria OraChicago, IL Tavern
  22. #21 7.3 Ranalli's Pizza Bar - Lincoln ParkChicago, IL Tavern
  23. #23 7.2 Bacino'sChicago, IL Tavern
  24. #23 7.2 Lusha PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  25. #23 7.2 Tommy's Tavern + TapSea Bright, NJ Tavern
  26. #26 7.1 Armand's PizzeriaElmwood Park, IL Tavern
  27. #26 7.1 Bongiorno's Cucina Italiana & PizzeriaChicago, IL Tavern
  28. #26 7.1 Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder CompanyChicago, IL Tavern
  29. #26 7.1 Geo's PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  30. #26 7.1 Piece Brewery & PizzeriaChicago, IL Tavern
  31. #26 7.1 Pizzeria PortofinoChicago, IL Tavern
  32. #26 7.1 Salerno's PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  33. #26 7.1 Star TavernOrange, NJ Tavern
  34. #34 6.8 Art Of PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  35. #35 6.4 Paisans PizzeriaCicero, IL Tavern
  36. #36 4.8 The Slice Hut at Neon GardensChicago, IL Tavern
  37. #37 1.1 Georgio's Gourmet PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  38. TBD Alla VitaChicago, IL Tavern
  39. TBD Almost Home TavernChicago, IL Tavern
  40. TBD Battle Hill TavernBrooklyn, NY Tavern
  41. TBD Bob's PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  42. TBD Bungalow by Middle BrowChicago, IL Tavern
  43. TBD Chicago's PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  44. TBD Crushed PizzeriaChicago, IL Tavern
  45. TBD D'Agostino's Pizza and PubChicago, IL Tavern
  46. TBD D'Amato's BakeryChicago, IL Tavern
  47. TBD Da Pizza DudeChicago, IL Tavern
  48. TBD Danny's Pizza PlaceChicago, IL Tavern
  49. TBD Dante's TavernChicago, IL Tavern
  50. TBD Darling Jack's TavernPhiladelphia, PA Tavern
  51. TBD DD's Pizza Co.Chicago, IL Tavern
  52. TBD Dicey's TavernNashville, TN Tavern
  53. TBD Dimmi Dimmi Corner ItalianChicago, IL Tavern
  54. TBD Dimo's Pizza WrigleyChicago, IL Tavern
  55. TBD Dino's Italian PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  56. TBD Dough BrosChicago, IL Tavern
  57. TBD Exchequer Restaurant & PubChicago, IL Tavern
  58. TBD Flo & SantosChicago, IL Tavern
  59. TBD Georgio's PizzaChicago, IL Tavern
  60. TBD Hancock TavernQuincy, MA Tavern

Tavern-Style Thin Crust pizza FAQ

Why is Chicago thin crust pizza cut into squares?

The party cut, or tavern cut, made the pizza easy to share in neighborhood bars. Small squares let a group grab pieces while drinking.

What is the difference between tavern-style and New York-style pizza?

Tavern-style has a thinner, crisper, cracker-like crust rolled with a pin and is cut into squares. New York-style is hand-stretched, chewier and cut into foldable wedges.

Is tavern-style or deep dish more popular in Chicago?

Many Chicagoans say tavern-style thin crust is what they eat most often. Deep dish is more often associated with special occasions and visitors.

What toppings are traditional on tavern-style pizza?

Italian sausage seasoned with fennel is the classic. Giardiniera, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and green peppers are also common.

More pizza styles