Old Forge is a small borough near Scranton in northeastern Pennsylvania, and it has a pizza tradition so strong that the town promotes itself as the pizza capital of the world. Its pizza comes in rectangular trays, served in pieces called cuts rather than slices, and in two main forms: red, with a sweet, onion-tinged sauce, and white, a double-crusted pie stuffed with cheese and seasonings.
Old Forge pizza is deeply tied to the town's Italian-American heritage and its coal-mining history, and to Friday night rituals that bring families into the town's many pizzerias. For outsiders, it is one of the most surprising pizza styles in the country.
The origin of Old Forge-style pizza
Old Forge's pizza tradition is rooted in the Italian immigrants who came to northeastern Pennsylvania's anthracite coal region in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Families baked rectangular pan pizzas at home, and over time those recipes moved into local restaurants and bars.
Long-standing pizzerias such as Arcaro & Genell, Revello's and Salerno's are among the names most associated with the style, and together with many others they turned Old Forge into a pizza destination. Local accounts differ on who served it first, and exact dates from the early years are not well documented, so much of that history survives as local lore.
Old Forge-style pizza dough and how it is prepared
Old Forge dough is pressed into oiled rectangular pans and allowed to rise, creating a thick, airy crust with a crisp, almost fried bottom. The oil in the pan is essential to the texture.
For white pizza, a second layer of dough goes over the fillings, creating a double-crusted pie. The top crust is often brushed with oil and seasonings before baking.
Old Forge-style pizza sauce, cheese and toppings
Red Old Forge pizza is topped with a sweet tomato sauce, often flavored with onions, and a cheese blend that varies by pizzeria. Many use a mix that may include American cheese, cheddar and mozzarella, which gives the pie a rich, creamy melt.
White Old Forge pizza is filled with cheese, often seasoned with onions, garlic and herbs, and sometimes broccoli or other vegetables, sealed between two layers of dough. Toppings on the red tend to be simple, and many locals prefer the pie plain to focus on the sauce and crust.
The oven and cooking technique behind Old Forge-style pizza
Old Forge pizzas bake in gas deck ovens in rectangular pans, commonly around 450 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, for roughly 15 to 25 minutes. The long bake crisps the oily bottom and melts the cheese evenly.
When done, the pie is cut into rectangles, the cuts, and served on the tray. Customers order by the tray, a full rectangular pie, or by the cut.
Lore and legends of Old Forge-style pizza
Old Forge's self-proclaimed title of pizza capital of the world is part promotion and part civic pride. The town has an unusually high number of pizzerias for its size, and loyalty to individual spots runs deep.
Friday nights are a pizza tradition in Old Forge, partly linked to the Catholic practice of avoiding meat on Fridays, especially during Lent. Pizzerias are packed with families and groups ordering trays of red and white, and the tradition is one of the town's defining rituals.
What makes a great Old Forge-style pizza, and how to eat it
Old Forge pizza is about a crisp bottom, a light crumb and a balanced sauce or filling. Look for these qualities.
- Bottom: crisp and golden from the oiled pan, not soggy or burnt.
- Crumb: light and airy rather than dense or doughy.
- Sauce: sweet and flavorful on the red, without being cloying.
- Cheese: creamy and well-melted, whether in a blend on the red or a filling on the white.
- White pizza: a crisp top crust with a well-seasoned filling.
- How to eat it: order a tray of red and a tray of white to share, and eat the cuts by hand.
Where to find Old Forge-style pizza
Old Forge and the surrounding Lackawanna Valley, including Scranton and nearby towns, are the heartland, and the style is found throughout northeastern Pennsylvania.
Outside the region, Old Forge-style pizza is rare, though transplants from the area sometimes seek it out at pizzerias in other parts of Pennsylvania and beyond.
Old Forge-Style in a One Bite review
Old Forge pizza gives a one-bite format an unusual test, since it comes in rectangular cuts and two very different forms. The red cut usually has a sturdy structure and a crisp, oily undercarriage that can shine, while the sweet sauce and cheese blend, which may include American cheese, can be divisive for palates expecting mozzarella. Grease from the oiled pan is a constant factor. The white pie, double-crusted and stuffed, is a different experience entirely from a cheese slice.